1
00:00:39,480 --> 00:00:42,130
To avoid fainting, keep
repeating to yourself:

2
00:00:43,816 --> 00:00:47,116
"It's just a movie, just
a movie, just a movie."

3
00:00:53,031 --> 00:00:55,181
Britain in the early 1980s
was suffering from its

4
00:00:55,201 --> 00:00:58,601
fair share of social ills:
rising unemployment,

5
00:00:58,811 --> 00:01:02,850
budget cuts, riots, strikes, war.

6
00:01:04,470 --> 00:01:07,407
But a new threat was
lurking around the corner,

7
00:01:07,419 --> 00:01:10,370
one that some said would
invade our homes, corrupt

8
00:01:10,590 --> 00:01:14,489
our children and would attack
the moral fabric of our society.

9
00:01:17,309 --> 00:01:19,452
There was a fairly high
level of unemployment.

10
00:01:19,789 --> 00:01:21,929
People fired from companies
that were closing, from factories

11
00:01:21,941 --> 00:01:24,348
that were closing, from
mines that were closing, used

12
00:01:24,349 --> 00:01:28,708
very often their compensation money.

13
00:01:28,709 --> 00:01:30,608
To start up as a video store.

14
00:01:31,268 --> 00:01:34,343
Anyone could do it, they didn't have any

15
00:01:34,355 --> 00:01:36,949
special experience, so a large number of

16
00:01:36,950 --> 00:01:41,208
people who had never had
anything to do with the movie

17
00:01:41,209 --> 00:01:42,547
business came together
and one supplied the other.

18
00:01:42,567 --> 00:01:45,528
And it was huge, absolutely gigantic.

19
00:01:45,906 --> 00:01:49,387
The growth was one
thousand percent overnight.

20
00:01:52,387 --> 00:01:56,686
Every week, new movies from
around the world hit the video shelves.

21
00:01:58,146 --> 00:02:03,051
New brands quickly emerged to meet the
growing demand for home entertainment.

22
00:02:04,066 --> 00:02:07,046
People came in with
briefcases full of cash.

23
00:02:07,886 --> 00:02:13,366
They want to open a video store, 20,000,
10,000, whatever, you give me movies.

24
00:02:13,526 --> 00:02:16,622
Because everything we had
at that time, people rented.

25
00:02:16,826 --> 00:02:21,806
We were doing so well at first that
we charged £50 per membership.

26
00:02:22,086 --> 00:02:25,605
The public liked any type of
cinema that was available at that time.

27
00:02:25,606 --> 00:02:27,551
And it went very well,
I don't know what kind

28
00:02:27,563 --> 00:02:29,704
of movie it was, whether
horror, action, comedy,

29
00:02:29,724 --> 00:02:33,844
childish or what, everything went very well.

30
00:02:34,045 --> 00:02:36,724
Britain is at the forefront
of the video revolution.

31
00:02:36,744 --> 00:02:40,684
We have more video recorders per
person than any other country in the world.

32
00:02:41,365 --> 00:02:44,143
Nowadays, more movies are
seen on video than in cinema.

33
00:02:44,764 --> 00:02:47,584
And this transformed the way British

34
00:02:47,596 --> 00:02:50,024
audiences accessed filmed entertainment.

35
00:02:50,663 --> 00:02:55,504
Until then, the only
films they saw were those

36
00:02:55,604 --> 00:02:58,923
that had been accepted
and subject to censorship

37
00:02:58,935 --> 00:03:02,343
voluntary in cinemas, or those they saw

38
00:03:02,344 --> 00:03:06,183
televised by the BBC or
one of the ITV companies.

39
00:03:06,502 --> 00:03:09,682
The majors weren't
particularly involved at the time.

40
00:03:09,723 --> 00:03:14,342
When I started, there were about 20
films from Warner Brothers and CIC.

41
00:03:14,782 --> 00:03:17,502
And it took them a long time to adapt.

42
00:03:17,602 --> 00:03:20,809
And now, suddenly, those,
if I use the term responsible

43
00:03:20,821 --> 00:03:24,262
distributors, found
themselves in competition.

44
00:03:24,263 --> 00:03:27,928
In competition with others, very often

45
00:03:27,940 --> 00:03:30,881
small people, with
limited resources, most

46
00:03:30,882 --> 00:03:33,983
They were not British,
who had made, for various

47
00:03:33,995 --> 00:03:37,181
reasons, films of a much
more extreme nature.

48
00:03:37,681 --> 00:03:40,501
And that they were very interested
in finding a British market for them.

49
00:03:40,521 --> 00:03:43,729
Ladies and gentlemen,
the bloodiest thing that

50
00:03:43,741 --> 00:03:46,680
has ever happened in
front of a camera: tobacco.

51
00:03:50,001 --> 00:03:54,200
The film that could only be made in
South America, where life is cheap.

52
00:03:54,860 --> 00:03:58,761
In reality, people were looking for
something they had never seen before.

53
00:03:58,960 --> 00:04:00,890
I mean, the only horror movies
they really saw in theaters

54
00:04:00,902 --> 00:04:03,020
were Dracula movies and
very, very, very scary movies,

55
00:04:03,021 --> 00:04:08,659
very soft Christopher
Lee or Vincent Price.

56
00:04:08,779 --> 00:04:14,999
There was nothing like
the SS camp or any other

57
00:04:15,000 --> 00:04:15,579
horror film that was
recorded on video afterward.

58
00:04:15,879 --> 00:04:22,239
And people were really very,
maybe very interested in seeing

59
00:04:22,319 --> 00:04:24,839
that kind of thing, which had
never been released in theaters.

60
00:04:24,859 --> 00:04:26,907
Movies they could actually watch at home.

61
00:04:28,158 --> 00:04:34,978
Love Camp 7 was actually filmed in
the location where the story took place.

62
00:04:36,738 --> 00:04:39,239
The idea that people
could rent or buy videos

63
00:04:39,251 --> 00:04:42,018
that they could show
at home, completely at

64
00:04:42,337 --> 00:04:44,591
outside of any of the provisions that,

65
00:04:44,603 --> 00:04:46,717
for example, restricted what people could

66
00:04:46,718 --> 00:04:50,797
seeing in the cinema, for some
it was something quite shocking.

67
00:04:56,057 --> 00:04:58,317
They were journalistic terms.

68
00:04:58,877 --> 00:05:04,716
Coined, I believe, by a journalist called
Peter Chippendale, who wrote a review

69
00:05:08,717 --> 00:05:13,616
from a video fair in Manchester,
late '81 or '82, in the Sunday Times.

70
00:05:13,716 --> 00:05:16,292
A very extensive story about
the products that were offered

71
00:05:16,304 --> 00:05:20,716
at this fair and that he
described as unpleasant videos.

72
00:05:20,776 --> 00:05:23,608
There used to be a program called Depend to

73
00:05:23,620 --> 00:05:26,195
Show, and it used to be every
six months, as I remember.

74
00:05:26,215 --> 00:05:29,395
It was like a big bazaar.

75
00:05:29,435 --> 00:05:32,943
I remember going to see Mike
Lee, and he had flesh-eating

76
00:05:32,955 --> 00:05:36,715
zombies, and he was very
pleased to show everyone

77
00:05:36,716 --> 00:05:41,594
the woman's face being
dragged towards the piece of wood

78
00:05:41,595 --> 00:05:44,799
from the broken window, and
what happens when she gets out.

79
00:05:44,811 --> 00:05:47,954
In the eye, it was
cut for the old film in

80
00:05:47,955 --> 00:05:50,446
theaters, but since
there was no law, he said:

81
00:05:50,458 --> 00:05:54,234
"Let's put this out, the
strong, uncut version."

82
00:05:54,235 --> 00:05:55,435
"Ah!

83
00:05:55,493 --> 00:05:55,994
Ah!

84
00:05:56,094 --> 00:05:57,294
Ah!

85
00:06:00,923 --> 00:06:04,895
There was a huge appetite for movies,

86
00:06:04,907 --> 00:06:09,082
and the more lewd, sexy, harsh or

87
00:06:09,083 --> 00:06:12,722
The more violent they
were, the better they sold.

88
00:06:14,982 --> 00:06:16,802
Oh yeah, that's fantastic.

89
00:06:17,962 --> 00:06:18,603
No.

90
00:06:18,743 --> 00:06:19,381
No.

91
00:06:19,502 --> 00:06:20,702
Not that.

92
00:06:21,441 --> 00:06:23,156
It's time for you to start thinking.

93
00:06:25,062 --> 00:06:26,341
Faces of death.

94
00:06:26,802 --> 00:06:28,002
No.

95
00:06:28,041 --> 00:06:28,682
No.

96
00:06:28,702 --> 00:06:29,342
It's time for you to start thinking.

97
00:06:29,343 --> 00:06:31,058
The driller's killer is approaching.

98
00:06:35,962 --> 00:06:40,720
Evil Dead was a huge success, it was the
biggest video hit of its time, of its year.

99
00:06:40,860 --> 00:06:45,300
I think it sold 50,000
copies in a year, which

100
00:06:45,301 --> 00:06:47,380
was, I think, between
£40 and £50 at the time.

101
00:06:47,400 --> 00:06:50,680
It was a video that
raised two million pounds.

102
00:06:50,920 --> 00:06:53,729
A video, as I say,
took off so quickly that

103
00:06:53,741 --> 00:06:56,500
when it was kind of
an annoying little thing.

104
00:06:57,440 --> 00:06:58,640
That?

105
00:06:58,700 --> 00:07:00,696
You know, it was like, oh, it'll go away.

106
00:07:00,720 --> 00:07:02,099
Oh, it just doesn't matter.

107
00:07:02,199 --> 00:07:04,619
Who cares? They're
just a bunch of perverts.

108
00:07:04,639 --> 00:07:07,420
And suddenly, when Evil
Dead had such a big impact,

109
00:07:07,919 --> 00:07:11,158
and suddenly the movie theater
chains say, ugh, what's going on here?

110
00:07:12,019 --> 00:07:16,759
The big distributors, their
anxiety was that their image

111
00:07:16,760 --> 00:07:20,338
and the image of the industry
they felt they had created

112
00:07:20,339 --> 00:07:23,099
for what I call the
conventional orthodox material.

113
00:07:23,738 --> 00:07:26,778
It was going to be
contaminated by associating,

114
00:07:26,779 --> 00:07:29,838
literally, on the shelves of retailers,

115
00:07:30,538 --> 00:07:34,597
you would find Mary Poppins next
to The Texas Chainsaw Massacre.

116
00:07:34,797 --> 00:07:38,750
And the people who produced Mary Poppins
weren't very happy with that juxtaposition.

117
00:07:40,558 --> 00:07:43,397
Without recognizable titles
or big stars, independents

118
00:07:43,417 --> 00:07:47,257
would rely on sensational
packaging to attract consumers.

119
00:07:48,677 --> 00:07:53,197
Well, in those days, I mean, it was a
shock tactic to advertise the product.

120
00:07:53,358 --> 00:07:56,757
So the hype was a bit
much for a lot of people.

121
00:07:56,758 --> 00:08:04,757
It was kind of but, you
know, clearly people were

122
00:08:16,777 --> 00:08:20,715
offended because a woman
was upside down, a crucifix type

123
00:08:20,716 --> 00:08:25,495
thing in captivity with obviously
threatening Gestapo guys.

124
00:08:25,775 --> 00:08:26,754
Like I say, I don't think there's
any way to think anyone would think

125
00:08:26,755 --> 00:08:29,515
they were posting nasty videos.
They were just putting out movies

126
00:08:29,516 --> 00:08:35,434
commercial. The video industry
is somewhat to blame for mounting

127
00:08:35,435 --> 00:08:40,455
advertising campaigns, which I believe
absolutely invited moral meddlers to

128
00:08:40,456 --> 00:08:45,919
Get to work. Mary
Whitehouse, a tireless activist,

129
00:08:45,931 --> 00:08:50,514
formed the National
Spectators Association

130
00:08:50,515 --> 00:08:54,685
and Listeners in 1963 and
promised to clean up television.

131
00:08:54,697 --> 00:08:59,493
In 1980, the Association had 30.

132
00:08:59,494 --> 00:09:03,953
000 members. The nasty videos
would give Whitehouse a new crusade.

133
00:09:06,253 --> 00:09:08,126
In fact, Mary Whitehouse
was one of the most astute

134
00:09:08,138 --> 00:09:10,113
and effective political
organizers we have ever had in

135
00:09:10,114 --> 00:09:12,323
this country. She was
a brilliant organizer.

136
00:09:12,335 --> 00:09:14,412
Her skill was to articulate
it and point it all in

137
00:09:14,413 --> 00:09:20,492
the same direction and
hit the target, which was the

138
00:09:20,512 --> 00:09:23,816
violence and sex, in the
videos. She was an open,

139
00:09:23,828 --> 00:09:27,292
easy target to attack,
and she did it brilliantly.

140
00:09:27,492 --> 00:09:31,385
The British public, the vast
majority of whom are understandably

141
00:09:31,396 --> 00:09:35,471
unaware of how serious
the threat the videos present

142
00:09:35,472 --> 00:09:38,811
unpleasant, particularly
for young people.

143
00:09:39,130 --> 00:09:41,662
What was becoming clear
was that the law was simply not

144
00:09:41,674 --> 00:09:44,470
coping with the massive
explosion of available material,

145
00:09:44,471 --> 00:09:50,390
much of which was
extremely violent, extremely.

146
00:09:51,470 --> 00:09:55,390
Obscene and, you know,
the law just didn't deal with it.

147
00:09:55,710 --> 00:10:00,050
They tear you apart, they tear you
apart, they tear you to pieces. Is...

148
00:10:03,119 --> 00:10:06,419
It's the light of the damn apes.

149
00:10:06,439 --> 00:10:08,947
Britain has the highest
proportion of national

150
00:10:08,959 --> 00:10:13,040
video recorders in the
world, and protesters fear

151
00:10:13,052 --> 00:10:16,100
has been that obscene videos
can fall into the hands of children.

152
00:10:16,259 --> 00:10:20,058
Certainly the titles of the works
themselves are a catalog of depravity.

153
00:10:20,898 --> 00:10:26,518
Cannibal Holocaust, SS
experimental camp, I spit on your grave.

154
00:10:26,519 --> 00:10:32,458
The battle, if we can put
it that way, in which we are

155
00:10:32,459 --> 00:10:34,737
involved, is a battle, it
is a battle for the whole,

156
00:10:34,749 --> 00:10:37,038
I was going to say, I'm tempted
to say the soul of the nation,

157
00:10:37,039 --> 00:10:40,217
that's not for me, but for the
whole quality of our culture.

158
00:10:40,597 --> 00:10:42,277
I liked Mary Whitehouse.

159
00:10:43,497 --> 00:10:47,785
She was a nice but
religious lady and she had

160
00:10:47,797 --> 00:10:51,997
every right to say
exactly what she thought

161
00:10:51,998 --> 00:10:55,636
about films she considered immoral.

162
00:10:55,637 --> 00:10:58,674
What bothered me was the fact that it was

163
00:10:58,686 --> 00:11:02,117
very difficult to mount
a campaign against it.

164
00:11:02,118 --> 00:11:02,476
And in fact, in the end, the countercampaign

165
00:11:02,816 --> 00:11:05,760
It wasn't so much to say that she was

166
00:11:05,772 --> 00:11:08,596
talking nonsense but to say that she was

167
00:11:08,597 --> 00:11:11,835
a silly old woman and laugh at her.

168
00:11:12,035 --> 00:11:13,975
But it is a problem.

169
00:11:14,755 --> 00:11:17,124
In reality, liberals don't rally or fight

170
00:11:17,136 --> 00:11:19,876
anything as well as the other side.

171
00:11:22,035 --> 00:11:24,035
The Daily Mail echoed the cause.

172
00:11:24,335 --> 00:11:25,615
They ran a campaign on the issue.

173
00:11:25,635 --> 00:11:30,494
It was a campaign to ban sadistic
videos, sensationally claiming

174
00:11:30,495 --> 00:11:32,775
that disgusting videos were
raping the minds of our children.

175
00:11:32,795 --> 00:11:35,859
I think that's a pretty
legitimate role for a newspaper

176
00:11:35,871 --> 00:11:39,174
to play, rather than putting
it aside and not focusing on

177
00:11:39,175 --> 00:11:45,234
in an area of ​​influence
that I think is enormous.

178
00:11:46,313 --> 00:11:49,294
Other national newspapers were
quick to jump on the bandwagon.

179
00:11:49,933 --> 00:11:52,206
Certain broadsheet newspapers
such as The Times and The

180
00:11:52,218 --> 00:11:55,453
Telegraph were equally guilty
of encouraging these stories.

181
00:11:55,454 --> 00:12:00,213
Like, you know, newspapers
like The Sun and The Mail.

182
00:12:00,593 --> 00:12:06,072
Well, I think what the press stands
to gain by encouraging these stories

183
00:12:06,073 --> 00:12:10,172
is that, in a completely hypocritical
way, it helps sell newspapers.

184
00:12:10,992 --> 00:12:13,410
You can have pages and
pages and pages talking

185
00:12:13,422 --> 00:12:15,853
about the horrors that
are in all these videos.

186
00:12:16,652 --> 00:12:20,752
And, you know, appeal to the
rather prurient senses of people here.

187
00:12:21,032 --> 00:12:23,121
And then at the end
of it all he says, oh, and

188
00:12:23,133 --> 00:12:25,431
of course, we need to
ban these nasty videos.

189
00:12:26,072 --> 00:12:30,952
And have entertained people for pages and pages
with details of what is apparently in them.

190
00:12:30,953 --> 00:12:31,151
But I also think this
plays with the agendas

191
00:12:31,391 --> 00:12:36,971
completely populist and
right-wing of these newspapers.

192
00:12:37,171 --> 00:12:42,270
You know, newspapers like The Mail
are always talking about the end of life

193
00:12:42,271 --> 00:12:47,211
as we know it and, you know, society
is in a terrible state of moral decay.

194
00:12:47,530 --> 00:12:51,029
And what we need is
strong moral leadership.

195
00:12:51,109 --> 00:12:52,769
Bring on Margaret Thatcher.

196
00:12:53,990 --> 00:12:55,430
The maintainer of the moralistic cause.

197
00:12:55,431 --> 00:12:57,910
That the video store was
not a family entertainment

198
00:12:58,109 --> 00:13:00,410
center, but a paradise of violent filth.

199
00:13:01,869 --> 00:13:04,309
Margaret Thatcher and Mary
Whitehouse shared similar

200
00:13:04,310 --> 00:13:07,749
views on the sanctity
of the family and home.

201
00:13:08,269 --> 00:13:12,528
Margaret Thatcher would have
looked favorably on Mary Whitehouse

202
00:13:12,529 --> 00:13:17,308
representing these kinds of
conservative and cautious values.

203
00:13:17,588 --> 00:13:20,787
I think it resonated pretty
well, I would have thought,

204
00:13:21,668 --> 00:13:23,828
With decent people like that, you see.

205
00:13:23,829 --> 00:13:29,827
Well, certainly Mrs Thatcher, when

206
00:13:30,108 --> 00:13:33,747
She was Prime Minister,
she listened to what we said.

207
00:13:34,088 --> 00:13:38,947
Thus, the headlines
impacted the reader and made

208
00:13:38,948 --> 00:13:42,227
them feel that there were
no longer problems, as for

209
00:13:42,667 --> 00:13:47,767
for example the salary or if
the hospital was functioning.

210
00:13:47,887 --> 00:13:51,907
The cause of all her problems
were the unpleasant videos.

211
00:13:57,606 --> 00:13:59,797
First of all, what is a nasty video?

212
00:13:59,946 --> 00:14:01,146
Difficult to define.

213
00:14:01,246 --> 00:14:04,846
They are constantly being
classified, but it's any movie.

214
00:14:05,046 --> 00:14:06,385
I mean, it turns out
it's on video, but it's a

215
00:14:06,405 --> 00:14:11,346
movie that includes
violence, sadism, horror.

216
00:14:11,605 --> 00:14:16,407
You know, the kind of horror movies
we used to call horror aren't so...

217
00:14:16,764 --> 00:14:18,445
They were mild compared to some of these.

218
00:14:18,465 --> 00:14:20,989
Things like Killer Driller,
they have horrible titles.

219
00:14:22,745 --> 00:14:27,584
According to the media, the disgusting video
marked a new low in sick entertainment.

220
00:14:28,265 --> 00:14:31,104
Even the adult industry
wanted to distance itself.

221
00:14:31,545 --> 00:14:33,355
The sex shop would sell sexual videos.

222
00:14:34,024 --> 00:14:36,704
Things like Driller Killer and

223
00:14:36,824 --> 00:14:38,083
dirty videos, nothing to do with sex.

224
00:14:38,103 --> 00:14:40,144
They are mainly violence, etc.

225
00:14:40,145 --> 00:14:42,336
, so we have nothing to do with them.

226
00:14:43,744 --> 00:14:46,463
By operating without regulation
or censorship, the industry

227
00:14:46,483 --> 00:14:49,463
video threatened a
good and decent society.

228
00:14:49,884 --> 00:14:52,143
The problem, of course, was the
children, and a lot of people took...

229
00:14:52,163 --> 00:14:56,523
they jumped into the argument to
say that if only people had done it.

230
00:14:57,462 --> 00:15:02,203
Violent or dirty videos,
children would not have access.

231
00:15:02,542 --> 00:15:06,062
People like Mary
Whitehouse said that people

232
00:15:06,063 --> 00:15:08,762
like me were serving children, minors,

233
00:15:09,043 --> 00:15:12,642
10 and 15 years old,
with murderer type movies.

234
00:15:13,622 --> 00:15:14,822
Trash.

235
00:15:19,372 --> 00:15:25,352
It's almost as if video nasty has
replaced The Conjurer and party games.

236
00:15:25,551 --> 00:15:26,751
That part is...

237
00:15:28,091 --> 00:15:29,831
It's actually stupid the
way people complain.

238
00:15:29,851 --> 00:15:30,851
It's not so scary.

239
00:15:31,011 --> 00:15:34,392
What's with things like The Living
Dead and fleshy zombies and all that?

240
00:15:34,631 --> 00:15:37,171
No, they are stupid.
They're not realistic, right?

241
00:15:37,270 --> 00:15:40,509
My mom doesn't really let me, but I
watch them when she's not around.

242
00:15:45,150 --> 00:15:48,055
The first thing is that it
desensitizes the child to violence.

243
00:15:48,410 --> 00:15:50,931
Then they start enjoying
it and that's worrying.

244
00:15:51,051 --> 00:15:52,528
The pow, wallop, they enjoy it.

245
00:15:52,790 --> 00:15:55,050
And the third part, and I
think it's the most important

246
00:15:55,070 --> 00:15:56,769
part, is that they
develop an appetite for it.

247
00:15:56,789 --> 00:15:58,349
I prefer horror movies.

248
00:15:58,369 --> 00:15:59,370
Why that?

249
00:15:59,510 --> 00:16:00,710
Because they are scarier.

250
00:16:01,190 --> 00:16:03,410
The right of adults to choose their own

251
00:16:03,411 --> 00:16:05,888
entertainment did not
concern moral crusaders.

252
00:16:06,110 --> 00:16:08,968
The purity of our children's
minds was at stake.

253
00:16:09,309 --> 00:16:11,969
And I'm afraid, you know,
people say, but why shouldn't

254
00:16:11,989 --> 00:16:15,828
adults be able to see this
kind of thing in their own home?

255
00:16:16,309 --> 00:16:20,609
I'm almost tempted to say that
people who make that kind of demand,

256
00:16:21,128 --> 00:16:23,808
knowing that children
are likely to see it,

257
00:16:23,848 --> 00:16:26,668
they are actually not
very mature and adults.

258
00:16:26,968 --> 00:16:29,388
And I had many confrontations

259
00:16:29,508 --> 00:16:31,248
with Mary White, once on television,

260
00:16:31,268 --> 00:16:35,547
regarding what she
classifies as disgusting videos.

261
00:16:36,587 --> 00:16:40,867
I mean, in my youth, I used to
enjoy watching a good Western movie,

262
00:16:41,007 --> 00:16:44,067
but that never made me want to
go out and start investigating people.

263
00:16:44,087 --> 00:16:50,967
It is difficult to conceive
images that harm people.

264
00:16:51,107 --> 00:16:53,965
I think you can conceive
images that bother people,

265
00:16:54,306 --> 00:16:59,307
or bother people, or excite
them, or even make them

266
00:16:59,506 --> 00:17:02,626
laugh, but the idea that
images actually hurt people,

267
00:17:03,386 --> 00:17:06,486
or harming people, harming society, I

268
00:17:06,865 --> 00:17:11,765
seems similar to the medieval
notion of witchcraft, I must say.

269
00:17:11,925 --> 00:17:13,306
It has an imitation effect,

270
00:17:13,825 --> 00:17:17,665
and I fear that some are trying to
discover what they have seen in real life.

271
00:17:18,025 --> 00:17:23,865
Not only is there the issue of
people who will copy what they see,

272
00:17:24,064 --> 00:17:28,564
and I would be the first to admit
that it will only be a minority of

273
00:17:28,565 --> 00:17:31,518
people, but what is the
effect of this on all of us?

274
00:17:31,764 --> 00:17:37,664
I mean, if you sit in
your chair, have your tea

275
00:17:37,804 --> 00:17:40,185
or whatever, your chips,
your beans and everything

276
00:17:40,224 --> 00:17:42,796
the rest, and with that,
you follow a diet of violence,

277
00:17:43,413 --> 00:17:44,890
So he seems to be in shock.

278
00:17:45,443 --> 00:17:48,244
Then there was the legal
profession, which often

279
00:17:48,464 --> 00:17:53,674
He used the excuse of exposing
himself to unpleasant videos,

280
00:17:54,243 --> 00:17:55,300
as they were becoming
known, as the reason why

281
00:17:55,324 --> 00:17:58,262
their client had committed
a particular crime.

282
00:17:58,563 --> 00:18:00,230
And the judges often accepted it.

283
00:18:00,343 --> 00:18:03,583
And when these cases were
reported, more fuel was added to the fire.

284
00:18:03,803 --> 00:18:08,942
The problem is that there is all this

285
00:18:09,162 --> 00:18:12,042
research, and not only
research, the meaning

286
00:18:12,262 --> 00:18:16,482
common, which says that
people do imitate what they see.

287
00:18:16,682 --> 00:18:19,402
That's what parenting is all about.

288
00:18:19,681 --> 00:18:26,281
I mean, she quotes, you know,
people saying that the evidence is

289
00:18:26,461 --> 00:18:30,401
overwhelming, that violence in the
media, that violence causes harm, etc.

290
00:18:30,780 --> 00:18:33,081
But in fact there is very
little in it that one can

291
00:18:33,101 --> 00:18:39,440
point to as part of any
kind of academic analysis.

292
00:18:39,980 --> 00:18:42,321
It is extremely unlikely
that a desensitization

293
00:18:42,322 --> 00:18:46,620
to watching violent films
could be the cause of

294
00:18:46,621 --> 00:18:50,239
someone goes out and
commits violence in the streets.

295
00:18:50,560 --> 00:18:52,940
The former Archbishop of
Canterbury, Lord Cogan, who has just

296
00:18:52,960 --> 00:18:55,980
witnessed some of the worst
unpleasantness, says he is shocked

297
00:18:56,000 --> 00:19:01,399
and warns parents...
Watch very, very carefully.

298
00:19:01,960 --> 00:19:04,379
Because the results in the
child's life and through him

299
00:19:04,380 --> 00:19:09,398
later in society can be much
greater than most of us think.

300
00:19:09,779 --> 00:19:12,939
You know, we have our
own views and there is a

301
00:19:12,940 --> 00:19:15,219
considerable amount of
research on the effects of

302
00:19:15,239 --> 00:19:18,138
terror, whether it introduces
nightmares or numbness.

303
00:19:18,738 --> 00:19:21,219
Or it leads to imitation, and so on.

304
00:19:21,318 --> 00:19:23,678
But they were not important in the debate.

305
00:19:23,778 --> 00:19:28,278
These are simply rude images that
we should protect our children from.

306
00:19:38,738 --> 00:19:40,297
What have you seen? Zombies.

307
00:19:41,577 --> 00:19:42,077
What's happening

308
00:19:42,557 --> 00:19:43,877
in that?

309
00:19:44,617 --> 00:19:48,497
Zombies running around and killing people
with blood pouring out of their heads.

310
00:19:48,917 --> 00:19:51,096
You see a lot of people
having their heads

311
00:19:51,097 --> 00:19:53,917
cut off and being slaughtered everywhere.

312
00:19:54,237 --> 00:19:55,697
She pierced his head.

313
00:19:56,037 --> 00:19:57,316
She pierced her head.

314
00:19:57,917 --> 00:19:59,966
And and...

315
00:20:00,226 --> 00:20:01,786
- Didn't it scare you?
- Yeah.

316
00:20:05,725 --> 00:20:10,206
I have never seen an unpleasant video.
I would not do it. I have too much...

317
00:20:10,207 --> 00:20:13,406
But how can you judge a nasty
video? You've never seen one.

318
00:20:13,426 --> 00:20:16,553
Look, if someone tells me,
while we receive these reports

319
00:20:16,565 --> 00:20:19,705
from Europe, the United States
and this country, that a video

320
00:20:19,805 --> 00:20:23,605
unpleasant in particular
contains that, that, that and that,

321
00:20:24,584 --> 00:20:31,544
I don't actually need to visually
see what I know is in that movie.

322
00:20:31,804 --> 00:20:33,764
I mean, I still think, "Oh,
well, have you seen it?"

323
00:20:33,765 --> 00:20:37,084
Well, you know, how can you
criticize something you haven't seen?

324
00:20:38,964 --> 00:20:41,565
And then you say, "Well,
yeah, I actually saw that."

325
00:20:41,566 --> 00:20:45,805
"Oh, so it's okay for you to see it, but you
want to prevent everyone else from seeing it.

326
00:20:45,864 --> 00:20:47,684
So we can't win in any way.

327
00:20:47,704 --> 00:20:51,123
I've seen some parts of
them because I had to.

328
00:20:51,643 --> 00:20:55,623
I don't dwell on it because I think
the images are quite disgusting.

329
00:20:56,043 --> 00:20:58,435
Responding to that
specific criticism, if you

330
00:20:58,447 --> 00:21:01,202
didn't see something,
you can't criticize them.

331
00:21:01,902 --> 00:21:06,141
You know, does a doctor have to have
cancer to diagnose cancer in a patient?

332
00:21:06,782 --> 00:21:07,982
Of course not.

333
00:21:10,802 --> 00:21:14,562
Growing public concern
about the proliferation of these

334
00:21:14,563 --> 00:21:17,563
types of videos has been fueled
by a powerful press campaign.

335
00:21:18,382 --> 00:21:20,162
The police were urged to act.

336
00:21:20,341 --> 00:21:23,246
But what exactly was the
crime that was being committed?

337
00:21:23,781 --> 00:21:28,722
I arrived at the Obscene
Publications Branch in 1981.

338
00:21:29,440 --> 00:21:33,001
And I think that after a
few months of being there,

339
00:21:33,221 --> 00:21:38,300
We discovered that there was
an explosion within the media.

340
00:21:39,580 --> 00:21:43,841
From external agencies
informing us of certain videos that

341
00:21:43,842 --> 00:21:48,399
were reaching the country
and that were totally obscene.

342
00:21:50,739 --> 00:21:53,480
Obscene Publications Act 1981.

343
00:21:54,440 --> 00:21:59,279
He considered obscene any
article that had a tendency to

344
00:21:59,280 --> 00:22:02,423
deprave and corrupt a significant
part of its target audience.

345
00:22:02,679 --> 00:22:06,519
I led the campaign to include
films in the Publications Law

346
00:22:06,520 --> 00:22:09,559
Obscene because it is proof
of damage, of harmful influence.

347
00:22:10,138 --> 00:22:14,019
It is not a test of what
is offensive to the man

348
00:22:14,158 --> 00:22:15,799
on the Clapham bus,
which we have had before.

349
00:22:15,819 --> 00:22:19,579
And I don't think anything should
be banned for being offensive.

350
00:22:19,818 --> 00:22:21,938
It should only be banned
for reasons of harm.

351
00:22:21,939 --> 00:22:25,137
Because obscenity
is a pretty difficult test.

352
00:22:26,078 --> 00:22:30,377
How do you prove that something
is depraved and corrupting?

353
00:22:30,417 --> 00:22:31,078
It's quite difficult.

354
00:22:31,337 --> 00:22:35,577
From my point of view, I didn't
know anything about videos.

355
00:22:35,997 --> 00:22:38,797
I don't think any of my staff, and

356
00:22:39,057 --> 00:22:40,876
I had 12 officers, I knew
something about videos.

357
00:22:40,896 --> 00:22:44,118
Driller Killer was one of the main ones.

358
00:22:44,416 --> 00:22:47,637
I spit on your grave, cannibal Holocaust.

359
00:22:48,357 --> 00:22:51,916
There were three that stayed with me.

360
00:22:52,577 --> 00:22:58,236
They were the first three that
caught my attention through the media.

361
00:22:58,456 --> 00:23:01,995
And as a result of that, we got

362
00:23:02,255 --> 00:23:04,160
copies, we saw them and I approached the

363
00:23:04,376 --> 00:23:07,576
Director of the Public Ministry.

364
00:23:07,856 --> 00:23:09,936
The reaction of the PPD was,

365
00:23:10,536 --> 00:23:14,195
"I give you my authority
to go to court" to seek

366
00:23:14,196 --> 00:23:16,875
an injunction under the
Obscene Publications Act.

367
00:23:16,876 --> 00:23:21,254
"Police forces across
the country could now

368
00:23:21,255 --> 00:23:23,636
confiscate any video they deemed obscene.

369
00:23:23,674 --> 00:23:27,035
With more than 15,000 video stores alone

370
00:23:27,354 --> 00:23:29,115
In England, they had a
lot of work ahead of them.

371
00:23:29,135 --> 00:23:32,294
Surely we're talking about a small

372
00:23:32,295 --> 00:23:34,754
minority of porn merchants, right?

373
00:23:34,755 --> 00:23:36,913
We are not talking about ordinary
merchants and large companies.

374
00:23:36,933 --> 00:23:39,374
No, please, I'm not talking
about pornography at all.

375
00:23:39,394 --> 00:23:42,553
There is no pornography of
any kind in any of these videos.

376
00:23:42,793 --> 00:23:44,753
They only relate to violence.

377
00:23:46,013 --> 00:23:48,654
Consequently, the police began raiding

378
00:23:48,655 --> 00:23:50,554
retailers, wholesalers
and distributors alike.

379
00:23:50,555 --> 00:23:53,252
Without a clear definition
of what they were looking for.

380
00:23:53,373 --> 00:23:56,953
There we are, we went down to
Thorne EMI, who were shocked.

381
00:23:57,753 --> 00:24:02,252
Let Scotland Yard's Obscene
Publications branch come.

382
00:24:02,633 --> 00:24:06,612
And I was known as Mr Video
Nasty with all those people there.

383
00:24:06,852 --> 00:24:09,900
Are otherwise respectable
companies getting involved in this?

384
00:24:10,013 --> 00:24:13,347
Oh yes, I'm afraid so. We have
public companies involved in it.

385
00:24:14,092 --> 00:24:15,378
Large public companies?

386
00:24:15,611 --> 00:24:17,972
Yes, we have Thorne EMI. Intervision.

387
00:24:18,652 --> 00:24:20,332
My God, how... I feel...

388
00:24:20,552 --> 00:24:26,091
All companies were in a big
dilemma following my arrival.

389
00:24:26,251 --> 00:24:27,451
What do they do?

390
00:24:27,570 --> 00:24:30,671
Distributors and retailers
had no more idea than

391
00:24:30,672 --> 00:24:32,990
the police which of
their films were obscene.

392
00:24:33,010 --> 00:24:36,370
The Publicity Director The
prosecutor's offices began to publish lists.

393
00:24:36,830 --> 00:24:39,811
But police enforcement varied
from county to county, and

394
00:24:39,812 --> 00:24:43,650
titles were added and removed
from the list without notice.

395
00:24:44,591 --> 00:24:46,731
The logical course of events
should have been that the Director

396
00:24:46,732 --> 00:24:50,070
of Public Prosecutions should
have seen the films before his

397
00:24:50,071 --> 00:24:52,890
premiere and then having given
instructions to the police forces.

398
00:24:52,910 --> 00:24:54,229
But they didn't.

399
00:24:54,289 --> 00:24:58,109
The police who decided to
prosecute the nasties were

400
00:24:58,110 --> 00:25:02,029
not what the censors
would call very film literate.

401
00:25:02,089 --> 00:25:04,989
They didn't really know
much about movies.

402
00:25:05,309 --> 00:25:08,869
Then several embarrassing cases arose.

403
00:25:09,229 --> 00:25:12,708
They confiscated
Apocalypse Now, thinking that

404
00:25:13,029 --> 00:25:16,509
It was a nasty one called
Cannibal Apocalypse.

405
00:25:16,848 --> 00:25:22,808
They confiscated El Mejor Caballito, or House
in Texas, a rather unremarkable musical.

406
00:25:23,329 --> 00:25:26,868
They also pursued a movie
called The Big Red One,

407
00:25:27,187 --> 00:25:29,907
presumably thinking it
was a pornographic film.

408
00:25:29,927 --> 00:25:35,147
In fact, it was a Sam Fuller
movie about his old WWII battalion.

409
00:25:35,408 --> 00:25:39,287
After visiting my store and checking
out 20 movies from my library,

410
00:25:39,847 --> 00:25:42,966
I took me and my wife home to see if

411
00:25:42,967 --> 00:25:45,627
she had any special movies at home.

412
00:25:46,067 --> 00:25:52,306
Then they took me to the local police
station and put me on bail, precisely,

413
00:25:52,867 --> 00:25:55,226
while they research my films.

414
00:25:55,986 --> 00:25:59,266
They took between 4,000 and
5,000 videos, which were probably

415
00:25:59,366 --> 00:26:03,226
all the products that were
on the shelves at the time.

416
00:26:03,386 --> 00:26:05,306
So they didn't come looking specifically.

417
00:26:05,326 --> 00:26:08,126
They just took everything
and then took them away.

418
00:26:08,306 --> 00:26:10,086
They probably had viewing parties.

419
00:26:10,106 --> 00:26:14,785
They took the three
directors and the junior buyer,

420
00:26:14,965 --> 00:26:16,185
who was a teenager, and
then returned threatening,

421
00:26:16,205 --> 00:26:18,965
saying that they could be
charged under Section 2 and the

422
00:26:18,966 --> 00:26:22,585
Section 3, what
subsequently happened to us.

423
00:26:22,965 --> 00:26:28,424
This was obviously quite
serious because it carried fines of

424
00:26:28,425 --> 00:26:31,854
up to £20,000 and he could
receive up to two years in prison.

425
00:26:31,924 --> 00:26:34,904
Both distributors and
retailers were accused

426
00:26:34,905 --> 00:26:37,764
​​under the Obscene
Publications Law and calls for trial.

427
00:26:37,784 --> 00:26:39,644
Well, we were all very
nervous at that time

428
00:26:39,645 --> 00:26:43,024
because they were sending
people for much less,

429
00:26:43,944 --> 00:26:48,443
just for the fact that they
were scared, they didn't

430
00:26:48,444 --> 00:26:51,044
defend, they didn't fight
and they were easy targets.

431
00:26:51,183 --> 00:26:52,783
Even though it was a farce,

432
00:26:53,443 --> 00:26:56,301
I really didn't feel like spending
two years in strange ways.

433
00:26:56,522 --> 00:26:58,542
I think I lost two kilos of weight.

434
00:26:59,823 --> 00:27:02,682
And not knowing on a
particular day if I was going

435
00:27:02,683 --> 00:27:05,962
to go to court and be
acquitted or go to jail.

436
00:27:06,343 --> 00:27:09,282
And so we were in front of
the stipendary magistrate, with

437
00:27:09,322 --> 00:27:12,562
Richard Dukan defending
or asking questions, the

438
00:27:12,642 --> 00:27:15,262
magistrate and the prosecution
of Police Chief Anderson.

439
00:27:16,882 --> 00:27:18,082
And Dukan...

440
00:27:18,922 --> 00:27:20,381
requested to the
prosecutor's office, he said:

441
00:27:20,401 --> 00:27:24,541
"Could you tell me how
many cases in the Greater

442
00:27:24,542 --> 00:27:28,841
Manchester" police have
investigated since 1982?

443
00:27:29,841 --> 00:27:32,520
"Of people being attacked
by flesh-eating zombies?"

444
00:27:32,521 --> 00:27:35,997
They showed two of the
films in court, I don't remember

445
00:27:36,021 --> 00:27:38,402
which ones they were,
and the jury was hysterical.

446
00:27:38,500 --> 00:27:39,700
They really loved them.

447
00:27:41,340 --> 00:27:43,500
Which was very good for my defense.

448
00:27:45,101 --> 00:27:48,420
In court, a lawyer for the
Director of Public Prosecutions

449
00:27:48,440 --> 00:27:52,379
described the material as
"a spectacle of violence."

450
00:27:52,619 --> 00:27:55,939
bloody", capable of depraving
and corrupting those who saw it.

451
00:27:55,940 --> 00:28:00,019
"Court cases across the country
only added to the confusion.

452
00:28:00,579 --> 00:28:06,039
In one court, a film may be condemned as
obscene, but in another, declared not obscene.

453
00:28:06,259 --> 00:28:09,019
Some defenders were
fined or even imprisoned.

454
00:28:09,039 --> 00:28:10,338
Others were acquitted.

455
00:28:11,159 --> 00:28:16,078
Several film titles were
found guilty of being obscene.

456
00:28:16,679 --> 00:28:18,418
But many were not.

457
00:28:18,438 --> 00:28:22,557
Many juries and many magistrates
decided that the unpleasant

458
00:28:22,558 --> 00:28:26,198
videos were not as harmful as
Mary Whitehouse seemed to think.

459
00:28:26,517 --> 00:28:31,117
She was trying to comply
with what she considered right

460
00:28:31,118 --> 00:28:34,397
in the industry and she
should not continue like this.

461
00:28:34,577 --> 00:28:39,059
And I got a message that the
police wouldn't bother us again.

462
00:28:39,397 --> 00:28:42,497
But lo and behold, the
police came in because at

463
00:28:42,498 --> 00:28:46,457
that time there was a
company in our premises, Palace

464
00:28:46,577 --> 00:28:49,537
Virgin Gold, and they
had a title called Evil Dead.

465
00:28:53,517 --> 00:28:59,876
I think my partner Nick really
took a risk by testifying for the film.

466
00:28:59,976 --> 00:29:02,975
We hire lawyers and take it to court.

467
00:29:03,075 --> 00:29:06,375
We basically wanted him to
be tried by a judge and jury.

468
00:29:07,116 --> 00:29:08,916
Unfortunately for the
government, the jury decided

469
00:29:08,936 --> 00:29:12,895
that Evil Dead was
not guilty of obscenity.

470
00:29:13,695 --> 00:29:17,475
So the government's program,
its campaign against Evil

471
00:29:17,495 --> 00:29:20,474
Dead, against the unpleasant
ones, was falling apart.

472
00:29:20,875 --> 00:29:23,209
Not all distributors were so lucky.

473
00:29:23,374 --> 00:29:27,034
David Hamilton Grant was a softcore porn

474
00:29:27,035 --> 00:29:30,255
producer whose video
label, World of Video 2000,

475
00:29:30,774 --> 00:29:33,933
released an Italian film, Nightmare.

476
00:29:34,934 --> 00:29:40,754
Grant retitled the film Nightmares
in a Damaged Brain and promoted

477
00:29:40,755 --> 00:29:43,674
it with a fancy Guess the Weight
of the Human Brain contest.

478
00:29:43,694 --> 00:29:46,613
Shortly thereafter, the
police paid him a visit.

479
00:29:47,494 --> 00:29:49,253
The prosecution questioned me.

480
00:29:49,713 --> 00:29:51,733
Who is going to see these movies?

481
00:29:52,293 --> 00:29:54,333
Why don't you think they are harmful?

482
00:29:54,573 --> 00:29:57,232
This scene where something

483
00:29:57,412 --> 00:29:58,932
terrible happens, isn't it disgusting?

484
00:29:58,952 --> 00:30:00,333
Don't you find it disgusting?

485
00:30:01,793 --> 00:30:06,720
It's very difficult to say, look,
there's violence in it, there's

486
00:30:06,732 --> 00:30:11,672
blood in it, but it's not really
particularly harmful to anyone.

487
00:30:12,471 --> 00:30:16,611
If you don't like seeing masses of blood,
you don't go to those kinds of movies.

488
00:30:18,032 --> 00:30:20,471
I don't remember, but this is what I said.

489
00:30:21,431 --> 00:30:24,428
It's not a classic, but it's
well executed, prompting

490
00:30:24,440 --> 00:30:27,391
the judge's irritated retort
that I can hardly believe.

491
00:30:27,392 --> 00:30:31,631
So was the German invasion of Poland.

492
00:30:33,410 --> 00:30:36,985
Well, if you have
judges like that, you know

493
00:30:36,997 --> 00:30:40,350
you've come to the
end of the road, really.

494
00:30:41,471 --> 00:30:44,143
Grant was sentenced
to 18 months in prison

495
00:30:44,155 --> 00:30:47,270
for supplying obscene
material for profit.

496
00:30:47,670 --> 00:30:51,870
The David Hamilton grant verdict
increased uncertainty and confusion

497
00:30:51,882 --> 00:30:56,209
within the industry, and action would
need to be taken to restore order.

498
00:30:56,730 --> 00:30:57,033
The David Hamilton grant verdict
increased uncertainty and confusion

499
00:30:57,045 --> 00:30:57,369
within the industry, and action would
need to be taken to restore order.

500
00:30:57,389 --> 00:31:01,887
The PDP's list of banned
nasties reached 79 at one

501
00:31:01,899 --> 00:31:06,409
point, but was finally settled
at 39 in December 1985.

502
00:31:07,609 --> 00:31:12,716
Films by Dario Argento, Wes Craven,
Abel Ferrara and Sam Raimi ranked

503
00:31:12,728 --> 00:31:17,848
alongside films such as The Last
Gestapo Orgy and Faces of Death.

504
00:31:19,928 --> 00:31:24,688
The filmmakers responsible for the
depravity were not called to testify.

505
00:31:25,408 --> 00:31:28,468
But it was his work
that caused the hysteria.

506
00:31:28,748 --> 00:31:34,548
I don't think it's
acceptable to ban movies.

507
00:31:35,347 --> 00:31:39,668
Not my movies, of course, not
my movies, but none of them.

508
00:31:40,066 --> 00:31:47,847
I have a lot of respect for the English,
for their democracy, for their serenity.

509
00:31:48,685 --> 00:31:50,019
Censorship is not democracy.

510
00:31:50,806 --> 00:31:53,426
We're all kids, you
know, we're all stupid.

511
00:31:54,686 --> 00:31:58,066
You kind of know there must be
people who censor these things.

512
00:31:58,466 --> 00:32:00,566
There are certain things
you're not supposed to show.

513
00:32:00,586 --> 00:32:06,705
And all kinds of mythologies
are invented to enforce that.

514
00:32:06,865 --> 00:32:10,305
You know, this is going to be harmful to
the children or this is, I don't know what.

515
00:32:10,325 --> 00:32:13,265
But I think there are actually
certain truths that are so

516
00:32:13,277 --> 00:32:16,386
painful and ugly that people
don't like to have them expressed.

517
00:32:18,485 --> 00:32:23,404
Cannibal, yes, he was born thanks to my son.

518
00:32:23,405 --> 00:32:27,363
At that time we watched
a lot of television.

519
00:32:28,464 --> 00:32:32,253
My son, who was only seven
years old at the time, complained

520
00:32:32,265 --> 00:32:36,143
about the Telegiornale
delle Venti because it always

521
00:32:36,144 --> 00:32:39,964
he reported on the death
of the red brigade members.

522
00:32:40,124 --> 00:32:42,823
It was a very cruel period.

523
00:32:43,183 --> 00:32:48,303
He didn't want to make a
complicated film just to make it.

524
00:32:48,363 --> 00:32:50,602
The film was dedicated
to these journalists.

525
00:32:50,823 --> 00:32:53,347
These journalists who
did this kind of nonsense.

526
00:32:53,403 --> 00:32:56,703
In the end, at that time he didn't
want to make a commercial film.

527
00:32:56,723 --> 00:32:58,533
He wanted to make a real, tough movie.

528
00:32:59,363 --> 00:33:03,981
I tried to make it quite difficult.

529
00:33:04,802 --> 00:33:10,562
The images were absolutely for children.

530
00:33:10,981 --> 00:33:12,181
They were strong.

531
00:33:12,622 --> 00:33:13,842
But life is strong.

532
00:33:14,562 --> 00:33:18,858
He used to say, "Look,
I don't want to resort

533
00:33:18,870 --> 00:33:22,982
to the usual hypocrisy
of American cinema.

534
00:33:22,983 --> 00:33:28,241
At a certain point, you only see the
knife, but you don't see the wound."

535
00:33:29,760 --> 00:33:30,960
Let's do one thing.

536
00:33:33,141 --> 00:33:40,241
If we really have to walk this path,
let's walk it to the end, without hypocrisy.

537
00:33:40,560 --> 00:33:43,097
One of the interesting
things the film does is

538
00:33:43,109 --> 00:33:45,880
show how sexuality can
be perverted into violence.

539
00:33:46,120 --> 00:33:48,240
And it's ugly. It's terribly ugly.

540
00:33:48,460 --> 00:33:51,679
It was the first time,
really, the first time, that

541
00:33:51,680 --> 00:33:58,139
the camera did not flee
from the horror, but rather

542
00:33:58,479 --> 00:34:01,540
He remained there to witness it, observe

543
00:34:01,580 --> 00:34:03,628
it and, obviously,
present it to the public.

544
00:34:03,759 --> 00:34:05,839
I would hope someone would see that and say:

545
00:34:05,859 --> 00:34:09,118
"My God, I hope I don't
do anything like that."

546
00:34:09,119 --> 00:34:13,618
"Of course, 99% of politicians get
involved because they make a fuss, right?

547
00:34:15,218 --> 00:34:18,518
All these crazy things make a scene.

548
00:34:18,598 --> 00:34:21,899
Politics must be seen, it
must be read, it must be heard.

549
00:34:22,078 --> 00:34:24,058
If it is silent, who will notice?

550
00:34:24,078 --> 00:34:29,238
It was the system
introduced by an English

551
00:34:29,239 --> 00:34:31,239
governor, whose name
was Margaret Thatcher.

552
00:34:31,378 --> 00:34:36,238
She introduced this very
violent censorship against films.

553
00:34:36,876 --> 00:34:38,896
Thatcher was the one who had the idea.

554
00:34:39,577 --> 00:34:41,477
She gave violence to her enemies,

555
00:34:41,777 --> 00:34:44,737
because she sent the English to fight at

556
00:34:45,036 --> 00:34:46,657
other side of America,
and she didn't kill anyone.

557
00:34:46,677 --> 00:34:48,276
I don't know violence. Thatcher.

558
00:34:48,637 --> 00:34:50,176
So is my movie better?

559
00:34:50,177 --> 00:34:53,036
Or is it better to send a ship
to shoot at the Argentines?

560
00:34:53,437 --> 00:34:54,696
It is a work of art.

561
00:34:55,116 --> 00:34:56,676
What is the point?

562
00:34:57,597 --> 00:34:58,797
What is the point?

563
00:34:58,876 --> 00:35:02,375
Is it because it is puritanism?

564
00:35:03,055 --> 00:35:07,155
An ancient heritage of Christianity?

565
00:35:08,116 --> 00:35:09,955
I used to go to England very often.

566
00:35:09,956 --> 00:35:12,555
Luckily they never asked me

567
00:35:12,755 --> 00:35:14,916
passport, otherwise they
would have arrested me.

568
00:35:14,936 --> 00:35:17,995
As an author of who knows

569
00:35:18,315 --> 00:35:19,614
what, I asked him and wrote it down.

570
00:35:19,615 --> 00:35:20,815
I wrote it in church.

571
00:35:27,734 --> 00:35:32,454
I produced a short video
of excerpts from four videos.

572
00:35:32,753 --> 00:35:34,933
In the end I took it to
the House of Commons.

573
00:35:35,033 --> 00:35:36,394
I took it to the House of Lords.

574
00:35:36,414 --> 00:35:37,454
I took him to Strasbourg.

575
00:35:37,634 --> 00:35:41,033
First of all, can I ask you what the reaction of
the parliamentarians was to what you showed them?

576
00:35:41,053 --> 00:35:43,339
I think they were
horrified by what they saw.

577
00:35:44,293 --> 00:35:47,113
What kind of things, what kind
of clips were you showing them?

578
00:35:47,133 --> 00:35:50,153
Well, the three clips, or
there is an excerpt of six clips,

579
00:35:50,412 --> 00:35:55,133
"Driller Killer", "Snuff", "I Spit
on Your Grave", "Faces of Death".

580
00:35:55,134 --> 00:35:55,952
"In the House of Commons we saw

581
00:35:56,152 --> 00:36:00,153
people eating live monkey brains.

582
00:36:00,632 --> 00:36:02,680
This is absolutely true. You can laugh.

583
00:36:02,992 --> 00:36:05,992
But that's... Just a moment.

584
00:36:06,452 --> 00:36:09,611
The video industry
was eager to clean up its

585
00:36:09,612 --> 00:36:12,052
image following the
video nasties scandal.

586
00:36:12,072 --> 00:36:13,851
With the blessing of the
government, the Association

587
00:36:13,871 --> 00:36:15,691
British Video, together with the British

588
00:36:15,711 --> 00:36:18,251
Film Sensors Board, set out to establish

589
00:36:18,271 --> 00:36:22,451
a definitive system of self-regulation.

590
00:36:22,751 --> 00:36:25,561
The government, through the
Ministry of the Interior and the

591
00:36:25,851 --> 00:36:28,566
then Minister of the
Interior, assured us that they

592
00:36:28,611 --> 00:36:30,371
wanted us to succeed, that
they applauded our efforts and

593
00:36:30,391 --> 00:36:33,731
They were very reluctant
to legislate in this area.

594
00:36:33,791 --> 00:36:36,990
They did not want to be
associated with legal censorship.

595
00:36:37,430 --> 00:36:41,329
But with an election around
the corner and the moralists

596
00:36:41,610 --> 00:36:44,710
still not satisfied, the industry
could not be trusted to regulate itself.

597
00:36:44,730 --> 00:36:48,249
Mrs Thatcher, I mean, very, very
explicitly introduced into the Conservative

598
00:36:48,269 --> 00:36:55,489
election campaign the promise to
do something about disgusting videos.

599
00:36:56,169 --> 00:36:58,468
Model panic is very easy
to cause in this country.

600
00:36:58,488 --> 00:37:00,429
You only need a couple of newspapers.

601
00:37:01,809 --> 00:37:05,948
Painting nightmarish pictures
of the effects on children

602
00:37:06,089 --> 00:37:08,769
and so on, and everyone is
horrified and we all run inside.

603
00:37:08,789 --> 00:37:09,989
I mean...

604
00:37:10,569 --> 00:37:13,848
I had model panics in violent dogs.

605
00:37:14,448 --> 00:37:16,308
And it is always in that
situation, when there

606
00:37:16,328 --> 00:37:18,247
is model panic, that bad
legislation is approved

607
00:37:18,267 --> 00:37:21,668
because it is approved hastily.

608
00:37:21,908 --> 00:37:24,008
You know, "We should
legislate this. Stop it."

609
00:37:24,009 --> 00:37:26,927
"And they do it so fast
that they make mistakes.

610
00:37:28,387 --> 00:37:30,887
Mary Whitehouse was
eager to find a candidate

611
00:37:30,888 --> 00:37:33,365
within the House to champion the cause.

612
00:37:33,447 --> 00:37:38,487
Then she Mary said to Graham
Bright: "Well, you know, if you turn out

613
00:37:38,787 --> 00:37:42,606
elected, will you introduce a
bill to address this problem?"

614
00:37:42,607 --> 00:37:44,847
And then Graham Bright said publicly:

615
00:37:45,027 --> 00:37:47,107
“Yes, of course I will, Mrs. Whitehouse.

616
00:37:47,108 --> 00:37:50,226
"Some people think they look
a lot like the kind of Hammer

617
00:37:50,227 --> 00:37:52,845
horror movie that is sometimes
shown on late-night television.

618
00:37:52,865 --> 00:37:54,107
Of course, that is not the case.

619
00:37:54,127 --> 00:37:56,925
We are talking about scenes
that are truly horrible and leave

620
00:37:56,926 --> 00:37:59,486
nothing to the imagination:
body mutilations, cannibalism,

621
00:37:59,487 --> 00:38:04,366
gang rapes. That's
what a nasty video is.

622
00:38:04,386 --> 00:38:06,526
Of course, the officials of the
Ministry of the Interior and the

623
00:38:06,527 --> 00:38:10,205
parliament the rapporteurs who
were drafting the bill, which was later

624
00:38:10,206 --> 00:38:15,025
would make it an act, in the name of
Graham Bright, that he was actually

625
00:38:15,045 --> 00:38:16,985
a puppet in all of this, I mean, it
was the Home Office who were really

626
00:38:16,986 --> 00:38:19,805
doing this, behind the scenes,
and using Graham Bright

627
00:38:19,806 --> 00:38:21,685
as a vehicle for getting
this into the statute book.

628
00:38:21,705 --> 00:38:24,304
My bill is intended to
protect children, because

629
00:38:24,324 --> 00:38:27,685
I have no doubt, having
seen some of these, of

630
00:38:27,705 --> 00:38:30,564
that we really need to protect children
from those things, and there is no

631
00:38:30,584 --> 00:38:33,784
doubt in the minds of the members who
came and saw that program yesterday.

632
00:38:33,804 --> 00:38:39,144
I think a young man who sees that
could have his mind scarred for life.

633
00:38:39,483 --> 00:38:42,263
Bright's beliefs about the
dangerous effects of video

634
00:38:42,264 --> 00:38:45,483
violence reflected those of Mary
Whitehouse and the moralists.

635
00:38:45,503 --> 00:38:46,962
The Video Inquiry
parliamentary group was set up to

636
00:38:46,982 --> 00:38:51,603
investigate the viewing
habits of the country's children.

637
00:38:52,462 --> 00:38:56,642
Both former MP Graham
Bright and research director

638
00:38:56,643 --> 00:38:59,582
Clifford Hill declined to be
interviewed for this documentary.

639
00:38:59,602 --> 00:39:02,463
Research is being
done that will show that

640
00:39:02,464 --> 00:39:04,322
these films not only affect young people,

641
00:39:04,342 --> 00:39:06,321
but I think they also affect adults.

642
00:39:06,341 --> 00:39:10,021
They asked me if I
would lead an investigation

643
00:39:10,022 --> 00:39:14,942
to find out the facts
about what children really

644
00:39:14,943 --> 00:39:16,961
come home that would
impact and allow parliaments

645
00:39:16,981 --> 00:39:21,581
to give a rational debate on this issue.

646
00:39:21,842 --> 00:39:29,140
I'd rather not talk about
some of the weapons.

647
00:39:29,921 --> 00:39:33,400
Which the moralists
used to achieve their ends.

648
00:39:35,161 --> 00:39:41,340
I would be delving into areas of
possible defamation if I said what I know.

649
00:39:41,939 --> 00:39:46,679
I would just say that I found the methods
used and some of the tools they used.

650
00:39:47,219 --> 00:39:47,720
To achieve your goals.

651
00:39:47,721 --> 00:39:50,839
I was able to understand his
goals and the purity of his motives,

652
00:39:51,380 --> 00:39:53,939
but, in my opinion, the
means by which they

653
00:39:53,940 --> 00:39:56,740
achieved those goals were
sometimes questionable.

654
00:39:57,539 --> 00:40:00,059
More than a third of all minor children.

655
00:40:09,119 --> 00:40:12,607
The first time I heard about
the investigation carried out

656
00:40:12,619 --> 00:40:15,979
by the so-called Parliamentary
Video Research Group was

657
00:40:15,980 --> 00:40:19,207
when a newspaper headline
appeared saying that four

658
00:40:19,219 --> 00:40:22,458
in ten six-year-olds had
seen an unpleasant video.

659
00:40:22,459 --> 00:40:28,879
45% of children between 7 and
16 years old who attend schools

660
00:40:28,891 --> 00:40:34,837
Great Britain have seen one or
more of the so-called disgusting videos.

661
00:40:34,917 --> 00:40:39,136
And we managed to get our hands on the
questionnaire that was used in this survey.

662
00:40:39,397 --> 00:40:42,437
Then the PGVE very kindly
gave us the questionnaire.

663
00:40:42,736 --> 00:40:45,597
When we looked at it, we
were horrified by the design.

664
00:40:46,036 --> 00:40:47,336
Do you know what a questionnaire is?

665
00:40:47,356 --> 00:40:47,677
No.

666
00:40:47,916 --> 00:40:49,756
Can you guess what a quiz is?

667
00:40:49,776 --> 00:40:55,255
The problem was that there
were 113 movie titles on

668
00:40:55,315 --> 00:40:57,575
his questionnaire and it
took up more than six pages.

669
00:40:57,595 --> 00:40:59,816
Now, that is a very long questionnaire.

670
00:41:00,555 --> 00:41:03,096
And although the questionnaire
said at the beginning,

671
00:41:03,835 --> 00:41:08,715
"If you've seen these movies on video,
please tell us what you think of them," of

672
00:41:08,716 --> 00:41:14,175
course, on page two, the conditional "if
you've seen them" is quickly forgotten,

673
00:41:14,354 --> 00:41:18,654
and the kids go on to rate the movie title
whether you like the sound of it or not.

674
00:41:19,034 --> 00:41:20,954
So to demonstrate this, what we did

675
00:41:20,974 --> 00:41:24,714
was, I think in the end
we had four classes,

676
00:41:24,814 --> 00:41:27,034
of children of 11, 11, 12
years old, and we gave them

677
00:41:27,054 --> 00:41:32,053
the video questionnaire
of the parliamentary group.

678
00:41:32,414 --> 00:41:34,073
With an important change.

679
00:41:34,514 --> 00:41:37,714
We removed all the
obnoxious titles from the

680
00:41:37,715 --> 00:41:40,813
videos and added movie
titles that didn't exist.

681
00:41:41,353 --> 00:41:43,813
There were things like
Blood on the vampire's teeth.

682
00:41:43,913 --> 00:41:47,352
And then we substituted the
titles of these movies into the

683
00:41:47,353 --> 00:41:49,432
original questionnaire and
gave it to 11- and 12-year-olds.

684
00:41:49,433 --> 00:41:50,653
Now, behold,

685
00:41:51,312 --> 00:41:55,232
More than two-thirds of children say
they have seen movies that don't exist.

686
00:41:55,672 --> 00:41:57,434
What is the hospital of horrors like?

687
00:41:58,652 --> 00:41:59,932
It gives a little scary.

688
00:42:00,572 --> 00:42:01,772
What kind of movie is it?

689
00:42:01,932 --> 00:42:04,452
It has a lot of blood.

690
00:42:04,652 --> 00:42:05,852
A lot of blood?

691
00:42:08,911 --> 00:42:10,959
I can't say much about it, really.

692
00:42:11,172 --> 00:42:15,331
So we can see that the claim
that four out of ten children

693
00:42:15,332 --> 00:42:18,211
have watched unpleasant
videos must be seen in the

694
00:42:18,212 --> 00:42:21,010
context that, in fact, most
kids are going to say they've

695
00:42:21,011 --> 00:42:22,671
seen these movies because
they like the way they sound.

696
00:42:22,691 --> 00:42:27,750
I don't think it's a valid test
to give them fake degrees.

697
00:42:28,511 --> 00:42:34,090
I think it is a dishonest way
to conduct an investigation.

698
00:42:34,450 --> 00:42:36,830
I think our method was much better.

699
00:42:37,110 --> 00:42:41,539
We are very concerned that this evidence from
the parliamentary group's video investigation.

700
00:42:42,170 --> 00:42:48,190
It was being used to push a bill
that seemed draconian in its entirety.

701
00:42:48,210 --> 00:42:52,189
It doesn't seem
credible, but this is what

702
00:42:52,190 --> 00:42:55,350
dozens of British
schoolchildren do every day.

703
00:42:55,509 --> 00:42:59,229
But then there was a
huge push of government

704
00:42:59,230 --> 00:43:02,409
support behind the so-called Bright Bill.

705
00:43:02,668 --> 00:43:06,383
The report itself certainly highlights
that there is a very serious problem.

706
00:43:06,548 --> 00:43:09,808
Tonight the parliamentary
inquiry team said

707
00:43:09,809 --> 00:43:11,968
they were so concerned
about the effects of

708
00:43:11,969 --> 00:43:14,689
videos like these that called in
several prominent psychiatrists

709
00:43:14,690 --> 00:43:17,548
to find out how much damage
had already been caused.

710
00:43:17,708 --> 00:43:18,188
The British government
has decided that the bill

711
00:43:18,208 --> 00:43:20,307
Bright, if passed in
Parliament, would ensure

712
00:43:20,327 --> 00:43:22,648
that videos published in
Britain would have to be

713
00:43:22,649 --> 00:43:26,187
classified by a censor
appointed by the State.

714
00:43:26,188 --> 00:43:30,427
Those who would have to pay special
attention to watching the film at home.

715
00:43:30,626 --> 00:43:32,987
Normally the invoices
of individuals disappear.

716
00:43:33,007 --> 00:43:34,907
In 95% of them nothing happens.

717
00:43:35,167 --> 00:43:37,407
But it was at Christmas
that it became clear that the

718
00:43:37,408 --> 00:43:41,466
government was going to
support this private members' bill.

719
00:43:41,646 --> 00:43:43,075
And as far as I was concerned,

720
00:43:43,506 --> 00:43:48,066
Actually, my main motivation
was not to start engaging in too

721
00:43:48,067 --> 00:43:52,706
many questions of judgment about
whether or not this material was

722
00:43:52,906 --> 00:43:55,665
harmful, but to provide a
mechanism where experienced people,

723
00:43:55,685 --> 00:43:59,065
not including myself, would
determine whether or not it was.

724
00:43:59,165 --> 00:44:00,485
The Conservative members of
Parliament, because we are now

725
00:44:00,505 --> 00:44:02,204
talking about a Conservative
government, were left in no doubt

726
00:44:02,224 --> 00:44:05,825
which they were expected
to come forward and vote

727
00:44:05,885 --> 00:44:07,605
for, even though it was
a private member's bill.

728
00:44:07,625 --> 00:44:10,666
I remember that Mrs Thatcher,
the then Prime Minister, interrupted

729
00:44:10,686 --> 00:44:15,404
the conversations she was
having with the then Prime Minister

730
00:44:15,424 --> 00:44:18,604
Canadian Minister, Mr. Trudeau,
at number 10, to come to

731
00:44:18,605 --> 00:44:21,684
the House and record his
vote in one of the readings..

732
00:44:21,944 --> 00:44:24,745
The Prime Minister met other
MPs in the House of Commons

733
00:44:24,746 --> 00:44:27,164
today to show the government's
support for the new bill

734
00:44:27,165 --> 00:44:30,024
to take drastic measures against
so-called unpleasant videos.

735
00:44:30,044 --> 00:44:33,903
The bill's sponsor is now relieved that
these measures appear to become law.

736
00:44:33,923 --> 00:44:35,603
Well, honestly, I'm absolutely delighted.

737
00:44:35,623 --> 00:44:38,882
I mean, the Prime Minister made it
quite clear yesterday that she was

738
00:44:38,883 --> 00:44:41,002
behind the bill and that the
government was behind the bill and that

739
00:44:41,003 --> 00:44:44,813
she wanted the bill to pass the
House as quickly as possible.

740
00:44:44,923 --> 00:44:46,603
It was just worth it...

741
00:44:46,983 --> 00:44:53,182
No one is willing to oppose it and no one
wanted to incur the hatred of killing him.

742
00:44:54,222 --> 00:44:57,102
And Mrs Thatcher's displeasure.

743
00:44:57,322 --> 00:45:00,321
No one really wanted to stand up
and defend the nasty videos because

744
00:45:00,322 --> 00:45:02,542
they were being universally
condemned as the cause of everything,

745
00:45:02,543 --> 00:45:06,722
from plane crashes to
swearing on the playground.

746
00:45:07,141 --> 00:45:10,182
It's a simple division
between the fight of good

747
00:45:10,183 --> 00:45:11,822
and evil and these movies
are bad and therefore

748
00:45:11,842 --> 00:45:14,942
So, if you don't agree with us that they

749
00:45:15,062 --> 00:45:16,661
should be banned, then
you yourself are bad.

750
00:45:16,662 --> 00:45:23,681
So a wave of pomposity was
transmitted, basically, without any

751
00:45:23,741 --> 00:45:25,321
of the liberal forces, not very
strong at that time anyway, but

752
00:45:25,341 --> 00:45:28,560
None of the liberal forces in
Parliament did anything about it.

753
00:45:28,580 --> 00:45:29,780
Trash.

754
00:45:31,261 --> 00:45:36,161
The reason the bill made it through committee
was because everyone was cooperating.

755
00:45:36,859 --> 00:45:40,420
I never had to have a bill in the
11 years I was a guillotined minister.

756
00:45:40,880 --> 00:45:45,539
He believed in committee
stages, not as a way for

757
00:45:45,540 --> 00:45:48,560
people to obstruct and abuse
the parliamentary process.

758
00:45:48,819 --> 00:45:51,640
And what we did was put it
into a practical mechanism where

759
00:45:51,641 --> 00:45:55,099
I wasn't deciding, Mary
Whitehouse wasn't deciding, the

760
00:45:55,359 --> 00:45:57,979
Mrs Thatcher was not
deciding what people could see,

761
00:45:57,999 --> 00:46:00,319
but rather a group of people
who, rightly or wrongly,

762
00:46:00,339 --> 00:46:04,758
were deemed fit to do so, I could
make that determination on the videos.

763
00:46:05,398 --> 00:46:08,939
The government appointed
the British Board of Film Censors

764
00:46:08,940 --> 00:46:12,919
as the regulatory body to
enforce the Video Recordings Act.

765
00:46:13,239 --> 00:46:15,517
The A-Team category will
serve as the regulatory body

766
00:46:15,537 --> 00:46:17,797
and it will remain quite
liberal, in fact more

767
00:46:17,917 --> 00:46:20,377
liberal than most
countries in this world.

768
00:46:20,897 --> 00:46:24,437
Contrary to Mr Bright's
claims, over the next 15

769
00:46:24,757 --> 00:46:28,737
years, Britain would be subject to the
strictest censorship in the Western world.

770
00:46:29,116 --> 00:46:31,797
It is not surprising
that horror movies in

771
00:46:32,257 --> 00:46:34,781
particularly suffered
cuts and total bans.

772
00:46:34,956 --> 00:46:39,576
We had a catalog of about
300 titles that we had to

773
00:46:39,736 --> 00:46:42,537
withdraw, all of them, and
reissue after we had them

774
00:46:42,757 --> 00:46:45,329
certified, and that was a
very, very expensive process.

775
00:46:45,537 --> 00:46:48,535
You know, in some ways it
seemed a little unfair that the

776
00:46:48,536 --> 00:46:52,475
small distributors had to
pay as much as the big ones.

777
00:46:52,956 --> 00:46:56,515
A very, very large part
of distributors, stores and

778
00:46:56,516 --> 00:46:59,075
companies that had really
jumped on the bandwagon

779
00:46:59,076 --> 00:47:01,775
when the video started
they were gone due to the

780
00:47:01,776 --> 00:47:04,376
fact that they had to
delete all the catalogues.

781
00:47:04,415 --> 00:47:06,815
So on the one hand, it was partly
a question of censorship, but I

782
00:47:06,835 --> 00:47:10,495
think the most important thing was
how big companies took back control.

783
00:47:10,855 --> 00:47:15,735
Well, let's arrest some of them,
beat them, take them to court.

784
00:47:15,794 --> 00:47:18,774
So it was a way to
suppress, in many aspects,

785
00:47:19,495 --> 00:47:21,814
The importance of independents.

786
00:47:25,594 --> 00:47:29,273
21 years on, the
BBFC is still in charge of

787
00:47:29,274 --> 00:47:32,093
what the British public
can and cannot see.

788
00:47:32,614 --> 00:47:34,393
But in recent years, many of the original

789
00:47:34,413 --> 00:47:37,472
unpleasant things have not been cut,

790
00:47:38,153 --> 00:47:41,296
while others are still banned
in their unpurged form.

791
00:47:42,213 --> 00:47:44,733
With the advent of DVD
and the Internet, fans of

792
00:47:45,013 --> 00:47:47,133
cinema can easily acquire one of their

793
00:47:47,153 --> 00:47:49,534
favorite nasty movies
in foreign territories.

794
00:47:49,913 --> 00:47:54,273
The original DPP-39
boxes have become items

795
00:47:54,512 --> 00:47:57,372
collectible and some sell for
hundreds of pounds on eBay.

796
00:47:57,392 --> 00:48:00,612
I think it's ironic that The Evil
Dead is now a collector's item, with

797
00:48:00,632 --> 00:48:05,791
Sam Rainey directing it, and here
we are now putting together this movie,

798
00:48:05,931 --> 00:48:09,711
which 20 years ago I could have
made two years if I had been found guilty.

799
00:48:10,312 --> 00:48:11,512
The time has changed.

800
00:48:11,791 --> 00:48:13,572
It seems awfully silly now,

801
00:48:14,431 --> 00:48:16,230
but I would say.

802
00:48:17,151 --> 00:48:21,130
That Mary Whitehouse and
that group had every right to do

803
00:48:21,150 --> 00:48:23,511
exactly what they did if they
were genuinely shocked by these

804
00:48:23,512 --> 00:48:26,370
movies and actually thought
they were harmful or immoral,

805
00:48:26,970 --> 00:48:29,030
or susceptible to being
depraved and corrupt.

806
00:48:29,050 --> 00:48:33,871
But the other side should have flexed their
muscles a little more and said nonsense.

807
00:48:34,050 --> 00:48:36,690
We have been fighting nothing less than a

808
00:48:36,910 --> 00:48:39,410
battle for the total
quality of our culture,

809
00:48:39,930 --> 00:48:42,709
our faith, our democratic way of life.

810
00:48:43,170 --> 00:48:45,456
The days of nasty videos are over.

811
00:48:46,070 --> 00:48:48,589
I'm still here, the
audience is still here and

812
00:48:48,649 --> 00:48:50,745
they're still watching
the same type of film.

813
00:48:50,988 --> 00:48:54,069
So, Mary Whitehouse, what did
you really achieve? I don't know.

814
00:48:55,789 --> 00:48:56,884
I think his legacy is that the

815
00:48:56,908 --> 00:49:01,129
broadcasters and the
film industry are very

816
00:49:01,130 --> 00:49:06,569
more open now to question and surrender

817
00:49:06,928 --> 00:49:09,024
accounts, to be
accountable for what they do.

818
00:49:09,248 --> 00:49:14,668
I think the audience was assaulted,
so to speak, by this orchestration,

819
00:49:15,447 --> 00:49:18,427
Campaign to make us believe
that there was a problem

820
00:49:18,428 --> 00:49:21,908
when, in reality, we are
the ones who investigated.

821
00:49:22,707 --> 00:49:25,027
I think the evidence is very weak.

822
00:49:25,227 --> 00:49:29,307
I think the fact that the
Video Recordings Law is in

823
00:49:29,546 --> 00:49:32,067
the statute book, be accepted,
is because, I dare say,

824
00:49:32,087 --> 00:49:34,467
self-praise is not a
recommendation, as I always said

825
00:49:34,487 --> 00:49:37,407
my mother, but in reality
we made a sensible,

826
00:49:37,427 --> 00:49:39,687
objective decision, cold
and analytical judgment.

827
00:49:39,707 --> 00:49:41,846
We were not part of the hysteria.

828
00:49:51,666 --> 00:49:55,845
The British Board of
Film Censors opened its

829
00:49:56,125 --> 00:49:59,745
doors in 1912 and for
the next six decades

830
00:49:59,746 --> 00:50:01,426
would rank as the world's
leading film agency.

831
00:50:01,427 --> 00:50:05,618
And remove all filmed entertainment
intended to be shown to the British public.

832
00:50:08,494 --> 00:50:11,949
But by the late 1970s cinema
attendance was in decline

833
00:50:11,961 --> 00:50:15,584
and, as a consequence, the
BBFC's income was declining

834
00:50:15,585 --> 00:50:18,598
at its lowest level of all
time. The relevance of the

835
00:50:18,610 --> 00:50:21,704
board in the modern world
will be further undermined

836
00:50:21,705 --> 00:50:26,664
by the arrival of home video, which for
a brief period had no formal censorship.

837
00:50:31,503 --> 00:50:37,484
To compete with the big studios,
small distributors released films from

838
00:50:37,485 --> 00:50:42,583
around the world, packaged in eye-catching
ways to attract the attention of a

839
00:50:42,783 --> 00:50:48,603
growing and video-hungry audience.
Films that were often quite lewd

840
00:50:48,604 --> 00:50:51,317
and would certainly never make
it past the censors for exhibition

841
00:50:51,329 --> 00:50:55,044
film filled the shelves of
video stores across the country.

842
00:50:55,103 --> 00:50:58,942
But this period of unrestrained
home entertainment will be short-lived.

843
00:50:58,943 --> 00:51:01,916
Thanks to the tireless
campaigning of Media Supervisor

844
00:51:01,928 --> 00:51:04,982
Mary Whitehouse, the
national press and members

845
00:51:04,983 --> 00:51:10,701
of parliament, a new law
was introduced into the statutes

846
00:51:10,702 --> 00:51:13,363
to block the torrent of
unsorted garbage that was

847
00:51:13,375 --> 00:51:16,621
infiltrating our homes
and corrupting our children.

848
00:51:20,121 --> 00:51:23,336
As a designated body, under
the terms of the Recordings Act

849
00:51:23,348 --> 00:51:26,720
Video, the British Board
of Film Censors had

850
00:51:26,721 --> 00:51:28,920
to grant the public
age-appropriate films.

851
00:51:28,940 --> 00:51:30,107
The British Board of Film Censors had to

852
00:51:30,118 --> 00:51:31,401
give age-appropriate ratings to all films

853
00:51:31,402 --> 00:51:35,266
video intended for distribution.
This government-granted

854
00:51:35,279 --> 00:51:38,999
monopoly would ensure that
the BBFC was the only company

855
00:51:39,000 --> 00:51:44,060
on the planet guarantee to make a profit
with every video published in Great Britain.

856
00:51:44,899 --> 00:51:48,210
When the Video Recording
Law was being discussed,

857
00:51:48,222 --> 00:51:51,478
this was an ideal situation
because it could create a

858
00:51:51,479 --> 00:51:54,268
body that the government
could turn around and say:

859
00:51:54,280 --> 00:51:57,079
"Well, censorship has
nothing to do with us now."

860
00:51:57,080 --> 00:51:59,404
It is this body that will
have to take care of

861
00:51:59,416 --> 00:52:01,893
it," which was a wonderful
way out for politicians.

862
00:52:01,998 --> 00:52:04,130
The whole problem was
exacerbated by the fact

863
00:52:04,142 --> 00:52:06,238
that we had already gone to market before

864
00:52:06,239 --> 00:52:09,035
the enactment of the Recordings Law

865
00:52:09,047 --> 00:52:11,918
Video in 1985: there were
already 10,000 videos.

866
00:52:11,919 --> 00:52:14,605
They went on the market and
they all had to be classified as

867
00:52:14,617 --> 00:52:17,258
well. And the government
gave us three years to edit 10,000

868
00:52:17,259 --> 00:52:23,817
videos. So it was
really a wonderful gift

869
00:52:23,818 --> 00:52:26,377
when the Video Recordings
Act came into effect.

870
00:52:27,418 --> 00:52:31,837
Large sums of money
immediately arrived. Before

871
00:52:31,838 --> 00:52:35,503
this happened, before all
the money came in, the BBFC

872
00:52:35,515 --> 00:52:38,856
It was kind of a nice,
seedy hole in the wall and.

873
00:52:39,476 --> 00:52:43,776
Suddenly the thing took
on a kind of corporate sheen.

874
00:52:49,036 --> 00:52:52,856
From time to time we argued why
the Ministry of the Interior had to

875
00:52:52,857 --> 00:52:56,275
approve their rates and sometimes
we argued that this was the case.

876
00:52:58,075 --> 00:53:01,472
Exorbitants, who were incurring
unnecessary expenses and

877
00:53:01,484 --> 00:53:05,034
making overly elaborate
changes to their offices and things

878
00:53:05,035 --> 00:53:08,236
so they then had to be
passed on in the form of fees.

879
00:53:08,495 --> 00:53:10,789
The BBFC was now responsible for the

880
00:53:10,801 --> 00:53:13,794
acceptability of images
displayed in the home.

881
00:53:14,194 --> 00:53:16,211
And thanks to recent moral panics in

882
00:53:16,223 --> 00:53:18,462
the national press,
they had to be cautious.

883
00:53:18,714 --> 00:53:21,255
The law did not specify what

884
00:53:21,267 --> 00:53:23,495
censors were supposed to worry about.

885
00:53:24,193 --> 00:53:27,051
The original law only said that
they had to take into account

886
00:53:27,074 --> 00:53:32,253
the likelihood that the film
would be shown in the home.

887
00:53:32,493 --> 00:53:35,914
Now, I don't know what that
means because the whole point

888
00:53:35,915 --> 00:53:39,313
of home video was to have
your product shown in the home.

889
00:53:39,573 --> 00:53:44,874
In many homes there are no children.
So the balance was between.

890
00:53:46,173 --> 00:53:48,262
Guaranteeing the freedom of those adults.

891
00:53:48,274 --> 00:53:50,472
I think about a third of
households in the country

892
00:53:50,473 --> 00:53:53,393
don't have children.
They have rights too.

893
00:53:53,613 --> 00:53:56,712
We strongly suggest that you
say: "By virtue of your treatment

894
00:53:56,713 --> 00:54:02,671
of sex, violence, drugs,
blasphemy, da-da-da-da-da-da."

895
00:54:03,372 --> 00:54:07,091
And not just give him carte
blanche to censor what he saw fit.

896
00:54:07,612 --> 00:54:11,791
And the government said, “No, we cannot take
what they call the laundry list approach.

897
00:54:11,811 --> 00:54:16,091
"We have to trust that the censor will
use his common sense and judgment."

898
00:54:16,092 --> 00:54:23,970
That is fine when the Minister
of the Interior, his officials

899
00:54:24,130 --> 00:54:26,559
and the censors are sensible
and responsible people.

900
00:54:26,910 --> 00:54:32,669
BBFC director James Furman
was wary of the ways new

901
00:54:32,670 --> 00:54:34,649
technology could be used
and abused in the home.

902
00:54:34,669 --> 00:54:39,030
You can't control the age of your
audience at home. can you advise

903
00:54:39,689 --> 00:54:44,549
and you can impose penalties on
stores if they supply underage customers.

904
00:54:45,009 --> 00:54:48,289
But once it reaches the home,
it is in the hands of the parents.

905
00:54:48,389 --> 00:54:51,661
And some parents care and some don't.

906
00:54:51,673 --> 00:54:55,816
Plus, some kids are smart
enough to outsmart their parents.

907
00:54:57,809 --> 00:54:58,548
And they're not afraid to
say, "I'm not going to do this."

908
00:54:58,549 --> 00:55:03,168
"It was up to the censor, as the designated
body, to subjectively interpret the act.

909
00:55:03,409 --> 00:55:11,108
The pornography of violence is allowing

910
00:55:11,437 --> 00:55:13,728
physical process of injuries,
wounds, mutilations and torture.

911
00:55:13,748 --> 00:55:17,987
And again, for fun,
for voyeuristic interest.

912
00:55:18,527 --> 00:55:24,267
And that's the problem with them,
they don't encourage compassion.

913
00:55:24,567 --> 00:55:26,048
They encourage detachment.

914
00:55:26,148 --> 00:55:30,686
And then... I think James
really believed, at least

915
00:55:30,726 --> 00:55:33,298
at first, that he was
holding back the floodgates.

916
00:55:34,487 --> 00:55:39,386
And that he had allowed
us a glimpse of the terrors

917
00:55:39,387 --> 00:55:41,816
that could occur if you
had unregulated videos.

918
00:55:42,326 --> 00:55:47,307
And James saw it a lot, I think, his
job is to close those floodgates again.

919
00:55:53,856 --> 00:55:56,555
Between 1986 and 1988,
more than 10% of films

920
00:55:56,556 --> 00:56:02,035
submitted for video
classification suffered cuts.

921
00:56:02,415 --> 00:56:05,074
James Furman loved to censor.

922
00:56:05,154 --> 00:56:09,875
He considered himself a film
editor and loved to tinker with movies.

923
00:56:10,494 --> 00:56:16,054
So when several nasty videos

924
00:56:16,474 --> 00:56:18,194
were subjected to censorship,
he loved editing them.

925
00:56:18,214 --> 00:56:22,115
I don't think the public
realized that not only

926
00:56:22,154 --> 00:56:22,853
was he certifying and
labeling, but he was cutting.

927
00:56:23,054 --> 00:56:26,414
And often James, James Furman,
would show us these examples,

928
00:56:26,553 --> 00:56:29,053
who was proud of what he
had been able to do and the

929
00:56:29,054 --> 00:56:31,813
skill with which he had
exercised these cuts.

930
00:56:32,133 --> 00:56:36,593
Our standards are certainly
stricter on video than on film.

931
00:56:36,833 --> 00:56:42,433
Video is very difficult
because, of course, how

932
00:56:42,473 --> 00:56:45,872
you use it is entirely
in the hands of the user.

933
00:56:46,072 --> 00:56:48,406
I mean, you can see things out of order.

934
00:56:48,812 --> 00:56:51,993
When we watch a movie,
we watch it in context.

935
00:56:52,232 --> 00:56:53,899
That is seen from beginning to end.

936
00:56:54,052 --> 00:56:56,532
But in video, it is not necessary
to see things from the beginning.

937
00:56:56,552 --> 00:57:00,652
You can dip here and
there and, you know, you can

938
00:57:01,091 --> 00:57:05,932
Play it whenever you want
and you can change its meaning.

939
00:57:06,132 --> 00:57:09,432
If you hit the censor
and encouraged him to

940
00:57:09,433 --> 00:57:12,005
care about almost
anything depicted in movies,

941
00:57:12,551 --> 00:57:16,075
you would find him deciding that all
sorts of things should not be allowed.

942
00:57:17,371 --> 00:57:21,010
Although Furman never made public
what he considered objectionable,

943
00:57:21,151 --> 00:57:24,610
certain images would always
end up on the clipping list.

944
00:57:25,890 --> 00:57:26,451
Criminal and instructive

945
00:57:26,551 --> 00:57:29,089
behavior, such as explicit drug use.

946
00:57:29,750 --> 00:57:32,330
Dangerous weaponry, like stars

947
00:57:32,650 --> 00:57:34,936
throwing knives, butterfly
knives or nunchuckers.

948
00:57:35,630 --> 00:57:39,789
And without exception,
blood on naked female breasts.

949
00:57:41,409 --> 00:57:46,608
But how is it possible that
the brave examiners could

950
00:57:46,829 --> 00:57:49,730
handle the dangerous images from
which the rest of the country was protected?

951
00:57:49,750 --> 00:57:52,512
Our examiners observe
in a two-stage process.

952
00:57:52,648 --> 00:57:55,568
First, they must be
open to the film or video,

953
00:57:56,549 --> 00:57:58,109
and second, they have to be able to
capture the average audience member

954
00:57:58,110 --> 00:58:02,228
because they have to experience
it as the audience will experience it.

955
00:58:02,548 --> 00:58:07,149
On the other hand, when
they react to something

956
00:58:07,150 --> 00:58:09,428
that appears to be a
classification problem,

957
00:58:09,947 --> 00:58:12,368
They have to take a
step back and analyze it.

958
00:58:12,488 --> 00:58:14,767
And so it's a double reaction.

959
00:58:15,147 --> 00:58:19,227
They are having the emotional
reaction and they are always analyzing it.

960
00:58:19,348 --> 00:58:23,346
They observe themselves, observe
where their solar plexus reacts.

961
00:58:23,707 --> 00:58:26,136
We have to see everything
again on the small screen.

962
00:58:27,386 --> 00:58:29,587
Pretend you're watching it at home.

963
00:58:32,446 --> 00:58:37,626
I mean, pretty ridiculous about a lot
of it, but that's what had to happen.

964
00:58:37,946 --> 00:58:43,046
They would often get quite a bit of
money for not spending a lot of time

965
00:58:43,047 --> 00:58:47,166
deciding that the self they gave in the
film should also be applied in the video.

966
00:58:47,486 --> 00:58:49,885
The subjective nature of
the censorship process.

967
00:58:50,605 --> 00:58:53,525
It inevitably sparked heated
debate within the board.

968
00:58:53,545 --> 00:58:56,146
And James Furman's
opinions on that process

969
00:58:56,545 --> 00:58:59,445
They sometimes differed from
those of the other board members.

970
00:58:59,465 --> 00:59:02,805
Well, James Furman was a
very contradictory and quite

971
00:59:02,806 --> 00:59:06,024
ambiguous figure and, in
my opinion, very interesting.

972
00:59:06,385 --> 00:59:08,665
But yes, he certainly he was autocratic.

973
00:59:08,864 --> 00:59:12,444
There is a great deal of evidence
to suggest that he was autocratic.

974
00:59:12,604 --> 00:59:15,545
Evidence in particular from examiners

975
00:59:15,557 --> 00:59:19,283
who have since retired from the board.

976
00:59:19,423 --> 00:59:25,864
James Furman was
largely in charge and could

977
00:59:25,865 --> 00:59:28,503
eventually overrule the
rest of the board members.

978
00:59:28,523 --> 00:59:31,084
But this didn't happen
very often, I assure you.

979
00:59:32,023 --> 00:59:36,263
Especially in the so-called Soho Six,
everyone has a university education, etc.

980
00:59:36,343 --> 00:59:42,183
They were very vocal in their comments
about how cinema should be treated.

981
00:59:42,402 --> 00:59:44,622
So Jim, on the one hand, loved this.

982
00:59:44,722 --> 00:59:50,742
He liked and welcomed the idea of ​​creating
a forum for debate and discussion.

983
00:59:51,061 --> 00:59:52,842
But the other side of him,

984
00:59:54,262 --> 00:59:55,842
his much more authoritarian
side, there was always,

985
00:59:55,843 --> 00:59:59,761
I think, somewhere in
the recesses of his mind,

986
01:00:00,712 --> 01:00:04,432
The net result of this
discussion is assumed

987
01:00:04,433 --> 01:00:06,071
to be one in which
the forces of are known.

988
01:00:06,091 --> 01:00:10,250
Sanctified goodness,
sanctified that is to say by

989
01:00:10,251 --> 01:00:10,751
Fuhrman himself, would
reach the correct conclusion.

990
01:00:11,051 --> 01:00:14,623
What are you doing? I'm not worried
about that. You're not doing anything.

991
01:00:14,851 --> 01:00:17,610
Arrest! Just look. You're crazy!

992
01:00:18,091 --> 01:00:21,187
We are very concerned
about exploitative rape scenes.

993
01:00:21,871 --> 01:00:25,670
Because people can watch
them over and over again in the

994
01:00:25,671 --> 01:00:28,871
privacy of their living room and
go crazy and you know that can

995
01:00:28,872 --> 01:00:32,510
feed the fantasy of
quite disturbed people.

996
01:00:32,829 --> 01:00:39,230
Let me go! You know, James
infamously considered himself a better

997
01:00:39,231 --> 01:00:43,529
feminist than many women and I
know that some of the board examiners

998
01:00:43,530 --> 01:00:48,390
They found it very difficult
to deal with. We had a lot of

999
01:00:48,391 --> 01:00:51,709
movies that treated rape as
entertainment for a male audience.

1000
01:00:51,710 --> 01:00:55,648
And the audience was expected
to enjoy it as a sexual spectacle.

1001
01:00:55,649 --> 01:00:59,589
What we should eliminate
is behavior that we

1002
01:00:59,590 --> 01:01:02,548
believe will influence
people to behave badly.

1003
01:01:03,248 --> 01:01:06,567
There are some good
reasons to even cut things.

1004
01:01:07,568 --> 01:01:09,828
You should at least have the
courage to make it clear what those

1005
01:01:09,829 --> 01:01:12,908
reasons are, know what you think
those reasons are, and open them up

1006
01:01:12,909 --> 01:01:18,827
under discussion. And I don't
think we're always very good at that.

1007
01:01:19,687 --> 01:01:22,423
It's pretty mild. We're fucking horrible.

1008
01:01:22,435 --> 01:01:26,387
The Video Recordings Act did
not require the board to explain the

1009
01:01:26,388 --> 01:01:29,806
reasons for a given decision to
either the industry or the public.

1010
01:01:30,147 --> 01:01:34,105
The climate in the industry
following the nasty video scare was

1011
01:01:34,106 --> 01:01:37,926
such that some distributors
were cautious about what to stock

1012
01:01:37,927 --> 01:01:41,946
and certain films will be cut
before submission to the BBFC.

1013
01:01:42,347 --> 01:01:46,486
The censors also had an
informal means of power over

1014
01:01:46,487 --> 01:01:53,026
the film producer. If a film
producer produced some

1015
01:01:53,027 --> 01:01:55,545
controversial article and had
a dispute with the British Board

1016
01:01:55,565 --> 01:01:58,345
of Film Classification over
what he wanted to do with it,

1017
01:01:58,365 --> 01:02:01,766
or did not agree with the type of
certificate they proposed to grant

1018
01:02:02,264 --> 01:02:05,407
or may be threatening to
withhold certification altogether.

1019
01:02:06,185 --> 01:02:10,385
So there would often be a dispute
between the censors and the particular

1020
01:02:10,386 --> 01:02:12,524
producer about what you're going
to do. Are you going to give him this?

1021
01:02:12,544 --> 01:02:14,464
Do I have to delete
this and everything else?

1022
01:02:14,484 --> 01:02:17,164
Now, if the censor was bothered by this,

1023
01:02:18,464 --> 01:02:21,863
when that guy came
to certify another film,

1024
01:02:22,304 --> 01:02:25,344
They said, oh, how unfortunate.
You wanted to get this

1025
01:02:25,345 --> 01:02:27,963
out in time for Wimbledon
or Christmas or something.

1026
01:02:28,263 --> 01:02:30,376
What a pity, because
I'm afraid that by then

1027
01:02:30,388 --> 01:02:32,383
we won't be able to communicate with him.

1028
01:02:32,543 --> 01:02:35,663
We are three months
late. We are looking at

1029
01:02:35,664 --> 01:02:38,363
Mary Poppins and we're
watching, you know, and of course,

1030
01:02:38,942 --> 01:02:44,062
This put enormous pressure
on this producer not to fight with

1031
01:02:44,063 --> 01:02:47,540
the censors, to bite his
tongue and accept his decisions.

1032
01:02:47,561 --> 01:02:50,162
It was a power that was
not in the Recordings Act.

1033
01:02:50,282 --> 01:02:53,342
Video, but it was definitely
operating and I witnessed it.

1034
01:02:53,522 --> 01:02:56,475
I think the business was
pretty nervous for a while.

1035
01:02:56,822 --> 01:03:00,221
A lot of things were
rejected at the time,

1036
01:03:00,261 --> 01:03:02,661
anything they considered
to be nasty videos.

1037
01:03:02,681 --> 01:03:05,201
None of them would get
a certificate at that time.

1038
01:03:05,221 --> 01:03:12,261
So we lost a lot of what was
then a very good rental product.

1039
01:03:12,521 --> 01:03:14,961
And then I think the quality of
the films decreased even more.

1040
01:03:14,981 --> 01:03:19,600
I mean, if I remember
correctly, Evil Speak was cut

1041
01:03:19,601 --> 01:03:21,935
to about 14 minutes or
something stupid like that.

1042
01:04:01,168 --> 01:04:02,568
It wasn't just the video.

1043
01:04:02,569 --> 01:04:04,648
It was the unpleasant
videos that suffered cuts.

1044
01:04:04,668 --> 01:04:08,328
Many horror and adult films
fell into the hands of censorship.

1045
01:04:08,868 --> 01:04:12,588
In fact, sex films became quite
chaste in the wake of the act, exposing

1046
01:04:12,768 --> 01:04:17,107
less of the naked human body
than the average top-notch magazine.

1047
01:04:17,587 --> 01:04:22,306
I remember the first one
we removed from the BBFC.

1048
01:04:22,446 --> 01:04:25,847
I remember the line very
easily as if it were yesterday.

1049
01:04:26,747 --> 01:04:28,795
Butt glaze removal site.

1050
01:04:29,126 --> 01:04:32,526
And we all laughed a lot about it.

1051
01:04:32,527 --> 01:04:36,444
So we removed the throbbing
butt on top of the woman

1052
01:04:36,456 --> 01:04:40,706
and then removed the
film from wherever it was.

1053
01:04:40,766 --> 01:04:41,685
I don't remember what it was, but I

1054
01:04:41,785 --> 01:04:44,406
think we had to adapt to the times.

1055
01:04:44,446 --> 01:04:45,046
That was the law.

1056
01:04:45,226 --> 01:04:48,499
Some relatively mainstream
films became personal goals.

1057
01:04:48,511 --> 01:04:51,745
For Furman and they would not be
granted a certificate, even though they had

1058
01:04:51,765 --> 01:04:56,825
been widely available and had never
been banned in the years before the VRA.

1059
01:04:57,124 --> 01:04:59,665
Most notably the Massacre of

1060
01:04:59,845 --> 01:05:02,465
Texas, Straw Dogs and The Exorcist.

1061
01:05:02,525 --> 01:05:08,545
James Furman insisted that it would probably
be very damaging to young girls if they saw it.

1062
01:05:08,685 --> 01:05:10,785
And when we researched
it, interestingly, we had a

1063
01:05:10,805 --> 01:05:16,264
group of people who
hadn't seen the movie before.

1064
01:05:16,523 --> 01:05:20,184
We called them virgin exorcists
and a group of people had seen

1065
01:05:20,196 --> 01:05:24,044
it before when they were younger
and observed their responses.

1066
01:05:24,164 --> 01:05:26,941
And people who had seen
the movie before thought it

1067
01:05:26,953 --> 01:05:29,858
was much scarier than people
who hadn't seen it before.

1068
01:05:30,264 --> 01:05:34,407
So by today's standards, The
Exorcist isn't that scary of a movie.

1069
01:05:34,563 --> 01:05:38,043
I think he really felt that it was very,

1070
01:05:39,063 --> 01:05:39,642
A very, very disturbing movie

1071
01:05:39,762 --> 01:05:42,622
for teenagers, and he felt that

1072
01:05:42,862 --> 01:05:48,962
It would be harmful if they saw her.

1073
01:05:49,932 --> 01:05:51,132
Don't think he was right.

1074
01:05:51,782 --> 01:05:55,081
If a video did not have a BBFC certificate,

1075
01:05:56,232 --> 01:06:01,801
then the owner of the video store or the
distributor would be exposed to a heavy fine.

1076
01:06:01,981 --> 01:06:07,921
So those who did not have BBFC
certificates were now declared illegal.

1077
01:06:08,441 --> 01:06:10,731
I mean, I think the
Video Recordings Act has

1078
01:06:10,743 --> 01:06:13,241
been frankly a fucking
nuisance for a long time.

1079
01:06:13,261 --> 01:06:16,940
It prevented people from
at least easily seeing the

1080
01:06:16,952 --> 01:06:20,440
movies that many people
would like to be able to see.

1081
01:06:20,620 --> 01:06:25,648
The only way to get
nasty videos like Texas

1082
01:06:25,660 --> 01:06:31,080
Chainsaw Massacre or Evil Dead
after 1984 was on the black market.

1083
01:06:32,420 --> 01:06:35,260
The illegal status of
horror and violent sex films

1084
01:06:35,261 --> 01:06:40,299
generated a healthy black
market for uncertified videotapes.

1085
01:06:41,480 --> 01:06:44,321
Zines, festivals and fairs
would provide a space

1086
01:06:44,333 --> 01:06:47,318
for like-minded film buffs
to discuss and exchange

1087
01:06:47,319 --> 01:06:50,639
the forbidden fruits of
the pre-certificate era.

1088
01:06:54,599 --> 01:06:58,096
I started advertising
the dark side with some

1089
01:06:58,108 --> 01:07:01,678
nasty top video titles
to get people's attention.

1090
01:07:02,558 --> 01:07:03,798
Large representative sample of people.

1091
01:07:03,799 --> 01:07:07,998
People wrote asking for movies
they couldn't get anywhere else.

1092
01:07:08,317 --> 01:07:11,222
But sometimes you would get
some really strange answers.

1093
01:07:12,878 --> 01:07:15,477
As if they were written
with blood and all

1094
01:07:15,489 --> 01:07:17,817
kinds of monsters, some strange people.

1095
01:07:18,697 --> 01:07:22,004
They wanted weird
stuff, but weren't willing

1096
01:07:22,016 --> 01:07:24,996
to risk importing it, so they bit me.

1097
01:07:25,117 --> 01:07:26,356
It's a safer bet.

1098
01:07:29,586 --> 01:07:32,627
A 2018 film will almost
certainly have an adult theme

1099
01:07:32,628 --> 01:07:35,427
and could well contain strong
scenes of sex or violence.

1100
01:07:35,447 --> 01:07:37,166
Which could be quite graphic.

1101
01:07:37,367 --> 01:07:40,162
It may also contain
very explicit language,

1102
01:07:40,174 --> 01:07:42,866
which will often mean sexual profanity.

1103
01:07:43,106 --> 01:07:46,066
The video industry
adapted to the new regime.

1104
01:07:46,485 --> 01:07:51,247
But the dangers of video violence
were never far from the tabloid headlines.

1105
01:07:51,585 --> 01:07:53,728
Thank you for your time.
Enjoy the movie.

1106
01:07:57,785 --> 01:08:04,844
On August 19, 1987, Michael Ryan
walked out onto the quiet streets of

1107
01:08:05,005 --> 01:08:08,644
Hungerford, dressed in combat
gear and armed with several firearms.

1108
01:08:09,764 --> 01:08:14,524
Sixteen people, including
Ryan's mother, were shot

1109
01:08:14,704 --> 01:08:17,562
to death that afternoon,
before Ryan shot himself.

1110
01:08:18,165 --> 01:08:21,331
It wasn't long before the
media began to equate

1111
01:08:21,343 --> 01:08:24,534
these horrific events
with video violence.

1112
01:08:37,583 --> 01:08:39,857
I don't feel what happened in

1113
01:08:39,869 --> 01:08:42,322
Hungerford, and I don't feel...

1114
01:08:42,323 --> 01:08:44,362
What happened at Hungerford is shameful.

1115
01:08:44,382 --> 01:08:46,601
Can't you handle...
a lot of violence on screen?

1116
01:08:46,621 --> 01:08:47,242
Control this person on your set?

1117
01:08:47,282 --> 01:08:50,022
Michael Ryan was dressed as Rambo.

1118
01:08:50,082 --> 01:08:51,982
Well, no one knows that
he was dressed as Rambo.

1119
01:08:51,983 --> 01:08:53,982
You mentioned Death Wish.

1120
01:08:54,282 --> 01:08:55,601
Now, Death Wish 3.

1121
01:08:57,301 --> 01:08:58,581
Did you see it, Maria?

1122
01:08:58,681 --> 01:09:02,481
A body drop, a shooting,
every 90 seconds.

1123
01:09:02,482 --> 01:09:03,518
Can I interrupt just for a moment?

1124
01:09:03,542 --> 01:09:05,199
I would like to get an
independent opinion, if

1125
01:09:05,211 --> 01:09:07,081
possible, from our TV
expert, Jimmy Greaves.

1126
01:09:07,101 --> 01:09:08,301
OK.

1127
01:09:08,621 --> 01:09:11,601
When Kate Adie did a Panorama special,

1128
01:09:12,101 --> 01:09:14,740
seeing cases where...

1129
01:09:16,180 --> 01:09:22,040
It had been claimed that a movie or a
television show affected someone, that

1130
01:09:22,140 --> 01:09:26,300
they had gone out and committed a crime,
of the eight cases that were very clear,

1131
01:09:27,040 --> 01:09:29,760
of which, they said, there was
supposed to be compelling evidence, none

1132
01:09:29,780 --> 01:09:33,999
of them stood up to close scrutiny,
including that of Michael Ryan.

1133
01:09:34,299 --> 01:09:39,840
So those dramatic cases that
appear in the newspapers are

1134
01:09:39,880 --> 01:09:43,099
singularly uninformative and
the psychiatric evidence later.

1135
01:09:43,100 --> 01:09:44,139
..

1136
01:09:44,140 --> 01:09:46,818
..in the cases it hasn't
helped much either.

1137
01:09:47,079 --> 01:09:49,841
In times of enormous
national stress, people naturally

1138
01:09:49,918 --> 01:09:54,559
feel very, very upset about it
and want to blame someone.

1139
01:09:55,319 --> 01:09:58,638
And they don't want to
know that maybe one of

1140
01:09:58,678 --> 01:10:00,278
these killers just wasn't
right about their case.

1141
01:10:00,279 --> 01:10:03,818
They want to blame someone.
I think that's human nature.

1142
01:10:05,097 --> 01:10:08,657
So who can they blame?
The video is the obvious scapegoat.

1143
01:10:08,837 --> 01:10:13,357
When the Video Recordings
Act first appeared in statute, I don't

1144
01:10:13,458 --> 01:10:19,096
think the notion of harm was
actually mentioned in the law itself.

1145
01:10:19,556 --> 01:10:22,297
The notion of harm lurked in the background.

1146
01:10:22,937 --> 01:10:26,136
In the BBFC's own guidelines and things.

1147
01:10:26,296 --> 01:10:28,396
I think what happened was
that the notion of harm came

1148
01:10:28,397 --> 01:10:35,056
to the fore and was highlighted
when the Law was amended

1149
01:10:35,057 --> 01:10:37,977
of Video Recordings after
the murder of James Bulger.

1150
01:10:39,376 --> 01:10:41,995
On February 12, 1993,

1151
01:10:42,636 --> 01:10:47,615
Two-year-old James Bulger was
kidnapped from a Merseyside shopping centre.

1152
01:10:48,356 --> 01:10:53,455
His body was later found beaten to
death on a railroad track two miles away.

1153
01:10:54,075 --> 01:10:58,154
It turned out that he had been
murdered by two ten-year-old boys.

1154
01:10:58,395 --> 01:11:01,855
What initially brought the
Jamie Bulger case together

1155
01:11:02,394 --> 01:11:04,175
to the scare video.

1156
01:11:05,114 --> 01:11:08,914
They were the images of Jamie Bulger

1157
01:11:08,915 --> 01:11:12,735
being carried out of
the shopping arcade by

1158
01:11:13,074 --> 01:11:15,027
the two boys who finally killed him.

1159
01:11:16,094 --> 01:11:20,194
This was an image that
resonated with everyone.

1160
01:11:21,154 --> 01:11:26,813
It was constantly repeated
on the news and, as was said

1161
01:11:26,814 --> 01:11:30,892
at the time, represented
every mother's worst nightmare.

1162
01:11:31,773 --> 01:11:34,134
The public was shocked
by the case and the

1163
01:11:34,135 --> 01:11:37,433
media was quick to
depict the national outrage.

1164
01:11:38,493 --> 01:11:43,052
Soon after I joined the British.
Video Association in November 93,

1165
01:11:47,271 --> 01:11:52,351
The court case was underway and I
remember that probably a few weeks later

1166
01:11:52,572 --> 01:11:56,732
After I joined, the media suddenly
took over the idea that the video

1167
01:11:56,733 --> 01:12:00,891
industry was somehow responsible
for the murder of James Bulger.

1168
01:12:01,191 --> 01:12:04,052
In his summary, Lord Justice

1169
01:12:04,231 --> 01:12:06,071
Morland, the judge presiding over

1170
01:12:06,211 --> 01:12:08,069
the case, made the following statement:

1171
01:12:08,351 --> 01:12:11,250
"It is difficult for me to
understand how it is possible

1172
01:12:11,490 --> 01:12:13,776
that two mentally normal
children, "10 years old,

1173
01:12:13,851 --> 01:12:16,530
of average intelligence,
"committed this crime.

1174
01:12:17,131 --> 01:12:20,227
"It's not my place to judge
his upbringing," but I suspect

1175
01:12:20,330 --> 01:12:25,310
that exposure to violent films
"may be partly an explanation."

1176
01:12:27,270 --> 01:12:29,510
When we heard Justin's comment

1177
01:12:29,690 --> 01:12:32,689
Morland, when I heard it
on the news, I was stunned.

1178
01:12:32,789 --> 01:12:36,391
He was drinking a cup of
coffee and I almost dropped it.

1179
01:12:37,149 --> 01:12:40,816
Because there was nothing in the
trial to suggest that the children had,

1180
01:12:41,108 --> 01:12:43,469
in this terrible, terrible case,

1181
01:12:43,629 --> 01:12:45,249
but they had seen some video.

1182
01:12:45,289 --> 01:12:50,769
And of course, in any
case, him saying that

1183
01:12:50,770 --> 01:12:53,532
meant that the warp packs
would be upon us again.

1184
01:12:53,928 --> 01:12:55,128
♪♪.

1185
01:12:56,388 --> 01:13:00,587
That made the media get to work with

1186
01:13:00,747 --> 01:13:03,528
this story, and they
searched and searched

1187
01:13:03,747 --> 01:13:05,607
a possible title that was responsible.

1188
01:13:05,627 --> 01:13:09,147
They posed in the video
for Chucky, The Child's

1189
01:13:09,367 --> 01:13:12,208
Play 3, which was a Paramount title,

1190
01:13:12,387 --> 01:13:15,027
uh, that no one had commented on before.

1191
01:13:15,348 --> 01:13:20,867
One way or another, including a
video in that seemed very wrong to me.

1192
01:13:20,927 --> 01:13:24,467
Uh, and then this movie,
the face of a demonic doll,

1193
01:13:24,646 --> 01:13:27,266
Chucky, appeared on the
front page of the newspaper.

1194
01:13:27,587 --> 01:13:29,647
Because there was, you know...

1195
01:13:29,648 --> 01:13:32,427
And the juxtaposition of
Chucky and his face and these.

1196
01:13:32,428 --> 01:13:38,567
..the still photographs of these
two little children and this little victim.

1197
01:13:39,325 --> 01:13:41,606
It was appalling at a time when I think

1198
01:13:41,607 --> 01:13:44,125
public sensitivity was
probably very high.

1199
01:13:44,525 --> 01:13:47,206
Um, it seemed almost criminal to me.

1200
01:13:48,545 --> 01:13:51,545
And I know that the police who
interviewed the two children, um,

1201
01:13:51,546 --> 01:13:55,645
said that they weren't really
influenced by a child's game because

1202
01:13:55,646 --> 01:13:59,365
either... I don't think either
of us would have seen that.

1203
01:13:59,624 --> 01:14:03,804
However, what those guys did

1204
01:14:03,984 --> 01:14:06,080
to Jamie Bulger's body, you know,

1205
01:14:06,624 --> 01:14:09,244
They couldn't have
thought of it for themselves.

1206
01:14:11,004 --> 01:14:15,823
They must have... been
subject to some outside

1207
01:14:15,824 --> 01:14:18,284
influence to have come
up with what they did.

1208
01:14:18,304 --> 01:14:21,524
And I understand that
at... at one of the guys'

1209
01:14:21,544 --> 01:14:25,644
house, you know, some
of the really extreme videos

1210
01:14:25,645 --> 01:14:28,983
They were accessible to
them, or to one of them, at least.

1211
01:14:29,543 --> 01:14:31,883
Um, that, I think, is a fact.

1212
01:14:32,243 --> 01:14:36,943
They were able to establish
that the father of, um, one of the...

1213
01:14:37,222 --> 01:14:40,642
The boys, John Venables,
had seen, um, or rented,

1214
01:14:40,763 --> 01:14:44,522
Child's Play 3, um, a few
months before the... murder.

1215
01:14:45,023 --> 01:14:47,942
But since the son didn't
live at home at the time and

1216
01:14:47,943 --> 01:14:51,062
said he didn't really like
horror movies, which was later

1217
01:14:51,542 --> 01:14:54,541
demonstrated by psychiatric
evidence, he dismissed it as a

1218
01:14:54,741 --> 01:14:58,642
possibility and said it is
extremely unlikely, therefore,

1219
01:14:58,821 --> 01:15:00,940
that the film had anything
to do with the murder.

1220
01:15:00,960 --> 01:15:01,881
The real question is: why would the judge

1221
01:15:01,941 --> 01:15:07,001
Did Morland feel able to
make those comments?

1222
01:15:07,201 --> 01:15:11,580
There is actually nothing in the case to
suggest that the videos played a role in it.

1223
01:15:11,920 --> 01:15:17,240
But why did he feel like he
could make those comments?

1224
01:15:17,440 --> 01:15:22,700
Because there had been years
and years and years and years of

1225
01:15:22,701 --> 01:15:26,140
stories in the press about the
supposedly evil effects of the videos.

1226
01:15:26,720 --> 01:15:28,721
I would also like to know, for
example, why it was when the

1227
01:15:28,741 --> 01:15:33,439
police began to investigate
the families of the two boys who

1228
01:15:33,440 --> 01:15:38,599
They killed James Bulger, why
was they wasting their time going to

1229
01:15:38,600 --> 01:15:43,858
the local video store and finding
out what the families had rented?

1230
01:15:43,999 --> 01:15:45,379
What the hell does it matter?

1231
01:15:45,399 --> 01:15:48,618
It seems like an absurd and
ridiculous waste of time to me.

1232
01:15:50,878 --> 01:15:53,359
The media published a sensational story.

1233
01:15:54,239 --> 01:15:57,478
Unsurprisingly, vote-hungry
politicians did the same.

1234
01:15:58,359 --> 01:16:02,538
The new witch hunt was
led by MP David Alton.

1235
01:16:02,818 --> 01:16:04,918
The amendment aims to
introduce a new category of

1236
01:16:04,919 --> 01:16:06,858
not suitable for home
entertainment and will cover

1237
01:16:06,878 --> 01:16:10,997
around 3% of the videos produced

1238
01:16:11,257 --> 01:16:12,977
currently, the really
ultraviolent videos.

1239
01:16:12,978 --> 01:16:15,477
Which are having such a
detrimental effect on young people.

1240
01:16:15,497 --> 01:16:18,296
Do you think videos are a
contributing factor to this?

1241
01:16:18,356 --> 01:16:19,857
Does the level of violence
increase? Yes of course.

1242
01:16:19,858 --> 01:16:22,937
You see some children
playing in the streets and

1243
01:16:22,938 --> 01:16:26,736
they pretend to be not
so much gladiators but

1244
01:16:26,737 --> 01:16:29,036
people who have been killed in movies.

1245
01:16:29,376 --> 01:16:31,656
They don't play Donald
Duck in the streets, right?

1246
01:16:31,676 --> 01:16:31,935
No.

1247
01:16:32,056 --> 01:16:34,295
Shooting and killing
each other, or drugs.

1248
01:16:34,416 --> 01:16:37,436
My sister has three
kids, ages seven and ten,

1249
01:16:37,516 --> 01:16:39,756
and they say, "Mom,
can we go watch a video?"

1250
01:16:39,757 --> 01:16:43,135
Give them the card and they can come
back with whatever tape they want to watch.

1251
01:16:43,155 --> 01:16:45,376
And you think that, of course,
should be illegal? Oh yeah.

1252
01:16:45,396 --> 01:16:45,696
David Alton, who was

1253
01:16:46,175 --> 01:16:49,275
Liverpool MP,

1254
01:16:50,155 --> 01:16:55,475
proposed a draconian law
to modify the Recording Law

1255
01:16:55,675 --> 01:17:02,094
Video Act, which would
criminalize the provision of videos

1256
01:17:02,095 --> 01:17:04,810
that are not suitable for
viewing by families or children.

1257
01:17:04,855 --> 01:17:09,234
So effectively, that would have
banned anything above PG.

1258
01:17:09,735 --> 01:17:13,214
My very modest measure aims to solve

1259
01:17:13,374 --> 01:17:15,094
those, like Child's
Play 3, which contains

1260
01:17:15,114 --> 01:17:18,853
Graphic and gratuitous scenes that

1261
01:17:18,854 --> 01:17:20,010
should not be available in anyone's home.

1262
01:17:20,034 --> 01:17:21,793
And I think it is very
wrong that we do not

1263
01:17:21,794 --> 01:17:24,913
pillory the producers
of this pornography.

1264
01:17:25,673 --> 01:17:30,072
Because most people who
make movies like society to

1265
01:17:30,493 --> 01:17:35,032
I consider them well, and yet these
people who make these horrible

1266
01:17:35,033 --> 01:17:38,152
movies get away with it and
pose as decent members of society.

1267
01:17:38,172 --> 01:17:42,932
And I think that the people
who produce these things,

1268
01:17:43,052 --> 01:17:45,352
like those child murders,
which were related to the case

1269
01:17:45,372 --> 01:17:47,992
Bolger, they should
also be publicly ridiculed.

1270
01:17:50,332 --> 01:17:55,632
Alton had the backing of 80 Conservative
MPs and victory was within reach.

1271
01:17:56,011 --> 01:17:57,771
But at the last moment he found

1272
01:17:57,911 --> 01:18:01,092
himself facing an unlikely opponent.

1273
01:18:01,610 --> 01:18:06,690
We cut more videos about violence in this
country than anywhere else in the world.

1274
01:18:06,770 --> 01:18:09,271
There is no other country
that reduces so many.

1275
01:18:09,471 --> 01:18:13,151
I campaigned very hard
against David Alton's amendment.

1276
01:18:13,850 --> 01:18:17,850
Because he got a lot of support
from both sides of the House.

1277
01:18:17,851 --> 01:18:21,910
For an amendment that
would have banned any video

1278
01:18:21,911 --> 01:18:26,089
that could constitute a
bad role model for a child or

1279
01:18:26,090 --> 01:18:28,810
be psychologically
disturbing for a child.

1280
01:18:29,090 --> 01:18:32,330
And I pointed out that that
would ban Schindler's List,

1281
01:18:33,209 --> 01:18:36,348
which surely no sane person wanted to do.

1282
01:18:36,609 --> 01:18:38,268
If James Furman is serious that he

1283
01:18:38,269 --> 01:18:40,209
and the British Board
of Film Classification

1284
01:18:40,210 --> 01:18:44,529
They can't tell the difference
between Schindler's List

1285
01:18:44,530 --> 01:18:46,309
or Toad in Toad Hall and
something like Child's Play 3,

1286
01:18:46,329 --> 01:18:50,029
So it makes you wonder what they
are doing in that job in the first place.

1287
01:18:50,049 --> 01:18:54,428
It's Hollywood shock films like Child's
Play that fuel the ugly video debate.

1288
01:18:54,448 --> 01:18:57,868
But David Alton's hardline
stance could affect much more.

1289
01:18:58,088 --> 01:19:00,008
The type of video that David

1290
01:19:00,208 --> 01:19:01,304
Alton wants to ban, or have

1291
01:19:01,328 --> 01:19:02,662
it banned, The Crying Game.

1292
01:19:03,508 --> 01:19:06,651
I probably have to say
that I agree with David Alton.

1293
01:19:06,787 --> 01:19:07,987
With reservations.

1294
01:19:08,247 --> 01:19:10,067
The reservations like
the fact that you could

1295
01:19:10,068 --> 01:19:11,367
hire something like that chaplain? But.

1296
01:19:11,387 --> 01:19:11,767
David Alton's bill suggests that

1297
01:19:11,927 --> 01:19:16,547
retail rentals should not be allowed

1298
01:19:16,548 --> 01:19:18,947
videos of movies that have a rating of,

1299
01:19:18,948 --> 01:19:21,427
say, 18 and that
contain violent material.

1300
01:19:21,746 --> 01:19:24,827
Now, it's not that he wants to
see all video stores like this closed.

1301
01:19:24,847 --> 01:19:26,946
In fact, there are many
very good videos on

1302
01:19:26,947 --> 01:19:29,866
the market today, movies
like Schindler's List.

1303
01:19:30,086 --> 01:19:35,607
But there are undoubtedly
many parents who share

1304
01:19:35,608 --> 01:19:37,545
my concern about the
levels of video material

1305
01:19:37,546 --> 01:19:40,451
ultraviolent that are increasingly
available in this country.

1306
01:19:40,926 --> 01:19:43,645
David Alton privately commissioned
a report on the dangerous

1307
01:19:43,646 --> 01:19:48,485
effects of video violence on
children to support his argument.

1308
01:19:48,765 --> 01:19:51,623
Before the Alton Amendment
was debated in Parliament,

1309
01:19:52,545 --> 01:19:55,664
Elizabeth Newsome,
professor of sociology at the

1310
01:19:55,665 --> 01:19:59,105
University of Nottingham,
published a report.

1311
01:20:00,024 --> 01:20:03,485
On the links between
screen images and children.

1312
01:20:03,904 --> 01:20:05,584
In the case of the Newsom Report,

1313
01:20:05,804 --> 01:20:13,183
which was released on April 1, We thought
that was an indication that it really

1314
01:20:13,724 --> 01:20:17,743
how it should be taken, that
maybe it was a joke, but no, it wasn't.

1315
01:20:18,133 --> 01:20:20,303
It was simply a statement, well

1316
01:20:20,423 --> 01:20:22,103
written, powerfully
argued in her rhetoric,

1317
01:20:22,123 --> 01:20:26,823
but which contained
very little evidence or

1318
01:20:26,824 --> 01:20:29,684
was considered part
of the scientific debate.

1319
01:20:30,122 --> 01:20:35,063
These are mainly newspaper clippings,
many from the local Nottingham newspaper.

1320
01:20:35,642 --> 01:20:37,282
In fact, she hadn't done any research.

1321
01:20:37,302 --> 01:20:39,422
What she had done, I think, was

1322
01:20:39,582 --> 01:20:42,183
look at a bunch of academic articles,

1323
01:20:42,302 --> 01:20:44,445
mainly coming from the United States,

1324
01:20:44,882 --> 01:20:48,142
all the media effects
surrounding it and this theory

1325
01:20:48,143 --> 01:20:52,282
that if you see violence on
the screen, your heart rate

1326
01:20:52,542 --> 01:20:56,721
increases and therefore
you are in danger of going out

1327
01:20:56,722 --> 01:20:59,981
and committing a serious
crime, murder, for example.

1328
01:21:03,951 --> 01:21:07,471
And that's why we
press furiously, all of us,

1329
01:21:08,051 --> 01:21:12,631
I think with the Video
Standards Council and the

1330
01:21:12,751 --> 01:21:14,971
BBFC were very involved, just to

1331
01:21:15,131 --> 01:21:18,410
make sure politicians understood

1332
01:21:18,950 --> 01:21:22,170
that the implications of what
David Alton was proposing, but

1333
01:21:22,330 --> 01:21:28,769
also that they understood that
the United Kingdom is already the

1334
01:21:28,770 --> 01:21:33,069
most tightly regulated video
industry in the free world.

1335
01:21:33,409 --> 01:21:36,748
And it really wasn't
necessary to go that far.

1336
01:21:37,209 --> 01:21:39,149
In the great debate over
the Alton Amendment,

1337
01:21:39,169 --> 01:21:40,968
The word freedom was never mentioned.

1338
01:21:40,988 --> 01:21:43,988
The only person that week
who used the word freedom was

1339
01:21:43,989 --> 01:21:49,409
me in all the articles I
wrote in the press and in the

1340
01:21:49,529 --> 01:21:51,449
radio interviews, because
I was on The World This

1341
01:21:51,450 --> 01:21:54,948
Weekend and on the Sky News
discussion program that Sunday.

1342
01:21:55,128 --> 01:21:56,748
Trying to overturn that amendment.

1343
01:21:56,788 --> 01:21:58,748
And it was ridiculous that he...

1344
01:21:58,768 --> 01:22:00,728
The censor was the one who spoke of freedom.

1345
01:22:00,748 --> 01:22:04,188
Fortunately, leaders
on both sides of the aisle

1346
01:22:04,328 --> 01:22:06,487
House, Michael Howard,
then Home Secretary, and

1347
01:22:06,507 --> 01:22:09,887
Tony Blair, who at the
time was spokesman for the

1348
01:22:09,967 --> 01:22:12,367
opposition, they took up
this point that I had raised.

1349
01:22:12,387 --> 01:22:14,748
The key is to find a way to overcome it.

1350
01:22:15,426 --> 01:22:20,047
To prevent extremely
violent, unnecessarily violent

1351
01:22:20,167 --> 01:22:23,427
videos from reaching people's
homes and, at the same time,

1352
01:22:23,428 --> 01:22:26,067
to ensure that we don't,
by casting the net so wide,

1353
01:22:26,087 --> 01:22:27,946
they end up preventing people
from seeing movies like The

1354
01:22:27,947 --> 01:22:30,662
Schindler's List, which
are clearly decent films.

1355
01:22:30,686 --> 01:22:32,877
Despite strong support
within the House, the

1356
01:22:32,945 --> 01:22:35,886
Home Secretary rejected
the Alton Amendment.

1357
01:22:36,945 --> 01:22:39,805
In the 24 hours prior to the
debate of an amendment,

1358
01:22:40,005 --> 01:22:41,925
that will probably be successful,

1359
01:22:42,145 --> 01:22:44,486
spreads a certain amount
of black propaganda.

1360
01:22:44,845 --> 01:22:47,885
I have always been
satisfied that the amendment

1361
01:22:47,886 --> 01:22:50,465
would achieve its goal of capturing 3% of

1362
01:22:50,585 --> 01:22:52,184
ultraviolent videos that I had my eye on.

1363
01:22:52,204 --> 01:22:54,565
But the Minister of the Interior
wants to rewrite it and put

1364
01:22:54,566 --> 01:22:57,985
it in his own words to achieve
precisely the same objectives.

1365
01:22:58,165 --> 01:22:59,504
I don't disagree with that.

1366
01:22:59,524 --> 01:23:01,604
If we had had the Alton
Amendment, the industry

1367
01:23:01,624 --> 01:23:03,984
would have been crushed
and there would have been

1368
01:23:04,164 --> 01:23:06,344
been impossible for
filmmakers, whether in

1369
01:23:06,664 --> 01:23:09,343
Hollywood or anywhere else in the world,

1370
01:23:10,124 --> 01:23:12,004
Hollywood, Bollywood, UK,
they couldn't have made any

1371
01:23:12,024 --> 01:23:18,023
profit from the movies because,
as everyone knows, most

1372
01:23:18,123 --> 01:23:23,383
of a film's income is derived
from video exploitation.

1373
01:23:23,763 --> 01:23:28,424
Distributors who violate these provisions
by providing videos to underage children.

1374
01:23:28,425 --> 01:23:32,683
Or videos that have not been
classified at all face strict penalties.

1375
01:23:33,603 --> 01:23:36,503
The video industry will have to

1376
01:23:36,504 --> 01:23:37,942
pay more attention to public concerns

1377
01:23:37,962 --> 01:23:41,002
and the board will not
be afraid to be stricter.

1378
01:23:42,882 --> 01:23:45,882
Modifications were made
to the Video Recording Law.

1379
01:23:45,981 --> 01:23:49,222
The supply of an unclassified
work now carried a penalty

1380
01:23:49,223 --> 01:23:52,762
of up to two years'
imprisonment and a £20,000 fine.

1381
01:23:54,242 --> 01:23:57,101
The provision of
classified work to a minor

1382
01:23:57,421 --> 01:24:00,601
age now carries a sentence
of up to six months in prison.

1383
01:24:01,221 --> 01:24:04,661
They are very, very
strict penalties for that.

1384
01:24:05,062 --> 01:24:10,221
And one has to wonder
if they were fair, in a way.

1385
01:24:10,301 --> 01:24:12,201
I think we were fair.

1386
01:24:12,920 --> 01:24:15,701
One unclassified video, two years

1387
01:24:15,820 --> 01:24:17,060
in prison, seems like a lot, right?

1388
01:24:17,080 --> 01:24:19,440
Following the Bulger case,

1389
01:24:19,860 --> 01:24:22,420
the Newsom Report, the Alton Amendment,

1390
01:24:23,640 --> 01:24:29,059
and the apparent, apparently, apparent
tightening of the Video Recordings Law,

1391
01:24:29,560 --> 01:24:33,719
because all these things
had firmly put the issue

1392
01:24:33,720 --> 01:24:37,478
of so-called nasty videos
back on the agenda,

1393
01:24:38,119 --> 01:24:42,939
In certain areas, some
police forces went back to

1394
01:24:42,940 --> 01:24:47,879
work and raided video
stores and video sellers.

1395
01:24:49,999 --> 01:24:52,557
For so-called nasty videos.

1396
01:24:52,597 --> 01:24:53,858
But I mean, I think
other than that, one of the

1397
01:24:53,859 --> 01:24:57,398
most shocking things
that has happened so far

1398
01:24:57,399 --> 01:24:59,638
over the years is the way the police,

1399
01:25:00,438 --> 01:25:03,534
With the aid and complicity of
those responsible for training

1400
01:25:03,577 --> 01:25:07,478
standards, they have frequently
raided the homes of collectors

1401
01:25:07,857 --> 01:25:11,137
of videos, who simply exchanged
videos between themselves.

1402
01:25:11,738 --> 01:25:14,697
You know, if I gave you a video,

1403
01:25:14,837 --> 01:25:16,957
apparently that counts as distribution.

1404
01:25:17,787 --> 01:25:20,357
And this has given carte
blanche to these people, to

1405
01:25:20,437 --> 01:25:23,296
the police and to the
training standards officers,

1406
01:25:23,857 --> 01:25:27,436
Break down people's
doors, confiscate their video

1407
01:25:27,596 --> 01:25:31,136
collections, confiscate their
recorders, take them to court,

1408
01:25:32,236 --> 01:25:35,236
You know, all accompanied
by terrifying stories

1409
01:25:35,645 --> 01:25:39,416
in the local newspapers
about these evil perverts.

1410
01:25:39,955 --> 01:25:43,875
I was at home, someone
knocked on the door, and there

1411
01:25:44,016 --> 01:25:49,815
were two training standards
officers and a police officer.

1412
01:25:49,895 --> 01:25:52,535
They had a warrant to search the premises.

1413
01:25:52,536 --> 01:25:55,475
And the training standards
officers were walking

1414
01:25:55,634 --> 01:25:58,295
around, like they had
just arrived in heaven.

1415
01:25:58,435 --> 01:26:01,197
They were just throwing
things into evidence bags.

1416
01:26:01,654 --> 01:26:06,614
My VCRs, video tapes,
everything video related.

1417
01:26:06,974 --> 01:26:10,313
They also took all my certified videos.

1418
01:26:10,634 --> 01:26:14,233
They took home videos
that I had, family videos.

1419
01:26:14,754 --> 01:26:17,333
Then it went to court
and there were three tapes

1420
01:26:17,334 --> 01:26:19,573
that they actually gave
me sample charges for.

1421
01:26:19,694 --> 01:26:22,314
They were Driller Killer,
Faces of Death and The Police.

1422
01:26:22,393 --> 01:26:23,873
And Violent Shit too.

1423
01:26:24,293 --> 01:26:27,352
I think they were just
looking for those titles for

1424
01:26:27,353 --> 01:26:29,213
the shock value and the
media coverage about them.

1425
01:26:29,233 --> 01:26:30,933
They did it in a
somewhat sensational way.

1426
01:26:30,953 --> 01:26:36,612
Even in court, apparently,
the judge was saying that

1427
01:26:36,613 --> 01:26:39,053
they didn't look favorably
on the fact that I was selling

1428
01:26:39,054 --> 01:26:42,771
movies with real-life
deaths, like Driller Killer.

1429
01:26:43,172 --> 01:26:45,612
They actually said that in court, which

1430
01:26:45,732 --> 01:26:49,512
I laughed at, and they scolded me for it.

1431
01:26:49,632 --> 01:26:52,071
They were trying to
make an example of me.

1432
01:26:52,532 --> 01:26:55,130
Which I really didn't like too much.

1433
01:26:55,491 --> 01:27:00,911
I guess it's one of those
disastrous routes that someone

1434
01:27:00,951 --> 01:27:03,331
can take and in the end all
they can do is come back

1435
01:27:03,351 --> 01:27:05,875
to be hanged for possession
of an unclassified video.

1436
01:27:06,390 --> 01:27:08,450
For the rest of the '90s, stories would

1437
01:27:08,550 --> 01:27:11,027
continue to appear in
the press equating the

1438
01:27:11,130 --> 01:27:14,589
video violence with
the collapse of society.

1439
01:27:16,290 --> 01:27:20,450
James Fairman occasionally defended
the rights of the country's spectators.

1440
01:27:27,120 --> 01:27:30,499
In 1998, Fairman awarded
certificates to two hardcore

1441
01:27:30,500 --> 01:27:34,639
adult films without
consulting the Home Office.

1442
01:27:35,559 --> 01:27:37,539
This measure caused
his retirement, but also

1443
01:27:37,559 --> 01:27:41,439
led to the partial
legalization of the sale of

1444
01:27:41,440 --> 01:27:43,869
hardcore videos in
authorized adult stores.

1445
01:27:44,678 --> 01:27:47,778
However, Britain still has
much stricter rules on the

1446
01:27:47,779 --> 01:27:51,297
sale of pornographic material
than the rest of Europe.

1447
01:27:54,378 --> 01:27:58,417
Robin Duval took over as
director of the BBFC in 1998.

1448
01:27:59,618 --> 01:28:04,077
Within a year, both The Texas
Chainsaw Massacre and The Exorcist

1449
01:28:04,078 --> 01:28:07,938
were legally available in Britain
for the first time in 15 years.

1450
01:28:08,556 --> 01:28:10,736
Straw Dogs followed in 2002.

1451
01:28:11,517 --> 01:28:15,736
In fact, numerous films that
had suffered cuts or bans

1452
01:28:15,957 --> 01:28:18,977
under Fairman they debuted
without any copycat criminal behavior.

1453
01:28:18,997 --> 01:28:20,426
Not a sensational frenzy.

1454
01:28:20,657 --> 01:28:24,217
What a change in the
British public that made

1455
01:28:24,218 --> 01:28:25,996
these images safe to
view just a few years later.

1456
01:28:26,016 --> 01:28:27,337
Get your hands off me!

1457
01:28:27,357 --> 01:28:27,895
No!

1458
01:28:28,075 --> 01:28:28,356
Ah!

1459
01:28:28,576 --> 01:28:29,776
Ah!

1460
01:28:30,256 --> 01:28:35,436
But it would be a mistake to assume that the scars
of that unpleasant era have completely healed.

1461
01:28:36,895 --> 01:28:41,135
Eroticized sexual
violence still attracts the

1462
01:28:41,136 --> 01:28:43,660
attention of censors
and often requires cuts.

1463
01:28:43,715 --> 01:28:45,955
But at least now the board
of directors is more open and

1464
01:28:45,956 --> 01:28:49,354
explains to the distributor the
legal reasons for its decisions.

1465
01:28:51,494 --> 01:28:56,795
In 2005, only 4% of movies
rated for home video were cut.

1466
01:28:57,455 --> 01:29:01,895
Could the notion of violent
video threatening our society

1467
01:29:01,896 --> 01:29:05,834
become a strange footnote
in recent British history?

1468
01:29:09,214 --> 01:29:10,554
Values ​​are changing.

1469
01:29:10,953 --> 01:29:14,154
I think that's the case too.

1470
01:29:14,214 --> 01:29:17,953
People are becoming more
semi-literate, which I think helps.

1471
01:29:18,653 --> 01:29:23,454
I think it is more difficult to
promote these types of campaigns.

1472
01:29:24,353 --> 01:29:28,473
It becomes increasingly difficult
to understand this as time goes by.

1473
01:29:28,573 --> 01:29:33,332
We now have 24-hour
porn available at the touch

1474
01:29:33,333 --> 01:29:34,612
of a button on the Internet
and everything else.

1475
01:29:34,632 --> 01:29:40,052
It seems almost innocently silly.

1476
01:29:40,633 --> 01:29:43,348
It's hard to know why
we are different in Britain.

1477
01:29:43,832 --> 01:29:46,912
It's one of the things I've
been asking in focus groups.

1478
01:29:46,932 --> 01:29:48,832
You know, it's the liberal
mind and the conservatives

1479
01:29:48,852 --> 01:29:52,291
say, "Well, we're British
and I can't explain it,

1480
01:29:52,292 --> 01:29:54,171
but, you know, “basically,
that's how we are.

1481
01:29:54,172 --> 01:29:56,411
"I think it's a quintessentially
British problem.

1482
01:29:56,431 --> 01:29:59,911
I think it brings together all
the things that are not attractive.

1483
01:29:59,992 --> 01:30:05,471
About British life really, I should say
English life really. The class structure,

1484
01:30:07,251 --> 01:30:14,110
the horrendously salacious and
populist press we have here, politicians

1485
01:30:14,271 --> 01:30:21,010
who seem to be wildly disconnected
from many aspects of modern life, a

1486
01:30:21,290 --> 01:30:26,650
sort of awful tendency to meddle with
bossy boots that I find deeply unpleasant.

1487
01:31:15,607 --> 01:31:16,858
Hello Hello hello.

1488
01:31:17,701 --> 01:31:20,853
Tight Shoes is mother.
Have you ever read Tight Shoes?

1489
01:31:21,647 --> 01:31:24,404
I am a walking nightmare,
a talking psychopath, the

1490
01:31:24,416 --> 01:31:27,186
king of the jungle like
a stalking gangster, who

1491
01:31:27,187 --> 01:31:30,066
Live life like a
firecracker, fast like a fuse.

